Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
115 reviews
MakeYourPuzzlesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are puzzlers and create happiness, one piece at a time!We know what puzzlers want and so we bring our know-how and expertise to the custom photo puzzle market - providing premium quality. MakeYourPuzzles is a brand that creates and distributes premium quality, yet affordable custom photo puzzles to puzzlers all over the world. From the traditional custom photo puzzles with 1 image to collage photo puzzles with up to 64 images - we got you covered!We believe in a future of endless possibilities, and we intend to take our customers on the journey of innovation and creativity through all our products.
MakeYourPuzzles (makeyourpuzzles.com) has 115 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
115 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I had questions regarding image quality before placing an order. They replied very quickly during our emails back and forth. The shipping was good and arrived in great shape. The box looks amazing. The puzzle will not be put together until after the birthday girl opens it. Hopefully all goes well, and all 1000 pieces are there.
By Zachary B.
Ordering a puzzle with a family photo printed on it was amazingly easy! Als, you was astounded by how quickly the beautiful puzzle was delivered. It was a great experience!
By Julie L.
Quick delivery- Beautiful custom made puzzle -quick response back from customer service- so much fun putting puzzle together- quality workmanship - will highly recommend and purchase more in the future.
By mls
Great puzzle quality! The resolution and colors were well represented. I like the size and feel of the pieces. Thanks for shipping it out quickly! Will be back for more!
By Mary
The puzzle I ordered did not have the number of pieces I thought I had ordered. After several emails back and forth, the company is sending a new puzzle at no additional cost. I'm very thankful and appreciative that this company is putting their customer satisfaction first! I feel sure once I have received the new puzzle that I will be ordering from them again ...
By Rebecca N.
quick turn around and so far pic looks great
By Robert R.
This was my first order through MakeYourPuzzles, and it will not be my last! I chose a photo from our trip to Switzerland and it came out beautifully!! Love the packaging and even more loved the free/fast shipping. I can wholeheartedly recommend you give them a try!!
By Linda V.
I had this puzzle made as a birthday gift for my sister. It's made up of 3 photos, one of my niece at her bridal shower, along with her sister (a bridesmaid) and the bride's 2 daughters ( also bridesmaids), and the other 2 photos of the 2 daughters of the bride at the wedding. My sister absolutely loved it. The puzzle is of good quality and arrived very quickly. I was very pleased with this purchase.
By Colleen E.
