Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
115 reviews
MakeYourPuzzlesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are puzzlers and create happiness, one piece at a time!We know what puzzlers want and so we bring our know-how and expertise to the custom photo puzzle market - providing premium quality. MakeYourPuzzles is a brand that creates and distributes premium quality, yet affordable custom photo puzzles to puzzlers all over the world. From the traditional custom photo puzzles with 1 image to collage photo puzzles with up to 64 images - we got you covered!We believe in a future of endless possibilities, and we intend to take our customers on the journey of innovation and creativity through all our products.
MakeYourPuzzles (makeyourpuzzles.com) has 115 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Showing 7 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
MAKEYOURPUZZLE did an excellent job. I received my puzzle quickly and it is a good quality puzzle. They sent shipping updates as well so I knew when to expect it. My only criticism is there wasn’t an option to allow for color or brightness correction. My puzzle was very dark compared to what I thought it would be. It doesn’t look as bright and colorful as I had hoped. But it is good quality and Mom loves it.
By Tammy
Great company! Made my custom puzzle with no hassle and delivered in a few days. I did notice that the finished product still had the black puzzle outline on the pieces but it wasn't too glaring. Wil definitely order again.
By Kartik
Great. Lost a star for making me type at least 10 characters
By Brian M.
Ensured my order would be processed and arrived to me within specific timeframe. However -1 star for miscommunication and not answering my questions in follow up emails. Due to this, it had given me anxiety and uncertainty regarding my order for about 5 days.
By Cyn A.
While the jigsaw puzzle pieces appeared to fit, when they did not, this is still the BEST quality jigsaw puzzle for custom photo puzzles that I have found. If you have a fairly clear, easy picture for your puzzle, should be happily enjoyed. I recommend MakeYourPuzzles for custom photo jigsaw puzzles.
By Theresa
This is the first time that I customized a puzzle. It was fun and got it quickly. It is of good quality. I got a 1000 piece puzzle with 64 photos of foursomes out on the golf course, many drinking birdie shots. The puzzle was like 17 inches by 26 inches, Should have been bigger, but when I customized and then ordered it, I did not take that into consideration. Next time I will as the individual pieces were quite small.
By Michael S.
I have not seen the finished puzzle as it was a gift. The image on the box seemed about 15% darker than the original I sent in but the recipient thought the pieces were well cut and the colors bright. The only real downside I encountered is that a 35mm full frame cropping is not available. Even if this meant a white border were present it would be preferable to me to not have to crop my original image.
By alan
