Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
115 reviews
MakeYourPuzzlesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are puzzlers and create happiness, one piece at a time!We know what puzzlers want and so we bring our know-how and expertise to the custom photo puzzle market - providing premium quality. MakeYourPuzzles is a brand that creates and distributes premium quality, yet affordable custom photo puzzles to puzzlers all over the world. From the traditional custom photo puzzles with 1 image to collage photo puzzles with up to 64 images - we got you covered!We believe in a future of endless possibilities, and we intend to take our customers on the journey of innovation and creativity through all our products.
MakeYourPuzzles (makeyourpuzzles.com) has 115 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
115 approved reviews, newest moderated first
My custom puzzle turned out great. Perfect size (500 pieces) and the pieces came in a good variety of shapes, not just one or two types of shapes. Colors look great on the thick "paper/cardboard" pieces and a very sturdy puzzle. Will glue it and frame it next.
By Mike G.
Speedy delivery and great quality. We really enjoyed the puzzle. The fact that it was eco‑friendly, made in the U.S., and from a family‑owned business was a real feather in the cap!
By H.W.
Quality puzzles, ships quickly. I’ve ordered three and made this one of my “go tos”when looking for a unique gift for someone.
By Kelley
I needed a custom puzzle done in a very short timeframe before the recipient leaves for 8 months, and MakeYourPuzzle was the only company that could make and deliver a custom puzzle within a week. It was also the cheapest option I found, even with the fast turnover. The puzzle ended up arriving two days earlier than planned, which was incredible. I honestly expected a lot lower quality for the price and speed, and was pleasantly surprised by the quality overall. The box was very nice and professional. The recipient didn't even know it was a custom puzzle, it was so fancy. A lot of times with puzzles, you get some pretty jagged edges. The pieces on this puzzle were immaculate. I am EXTREMELY pleased with my purchase and will 100% be using MakeYourPuzzles for my custom puzzle needs in the future.
By Em
We love our puzzle from last year, so we had some more puzzles created this year for gifts.
By P B.
It is fast and extremely reliable with sharp cuts in the puzzle for a sharper photo.
By Larry R.
I ordered this puzzle for a family member for Christmas and I can't wait to give it to him it is so unique and I'm sure it will be something that he will keep I'm so glad I discovered this website this gift is so beautiful
By Bonnie S.
I'm not well versed in editing photos and wanted a specific layered look of a single photo. Customer service advised me and I was able to figure it out and submit the look I wanted for the puzzle. It was shipping within a couple of days. Wonderful customer service. Thank-you!
By Puzzled & Satisfied P.
