Colors were vibrant
Colors were vibrant. Prompt delivery
By Margaret H.
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
115 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are puzzlers and create happiness, one piece at a time!We know what puzzlers want and so we bring our know-how and expertise to the custom photo puzzle market - providing premium quality. MakeYourPuzzles is a brand that creates and distributes premium quality, yet affordable custom photo puzzles to puzzlers all over the world. From the traditional custom photo puzzles with 1 image to collage photo puzzles with up to 64 images - we got you covered!We believe in a future of endless possibilities, and we intend to take our customers on the journey of innovation and creativity through all our products.
MakeYourPuzzles (makeyourpuzzles.com) has 115 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
115 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Colors were vibrant. Prompt delivery
By Margaret H.
Super fast turnaround and high quality.
By Rich
I have not seen the finished puzzle as it was a gift. The image on the box seemed about 15% darker than the original I sent in but the recipient thought the pieces were well cut and the colors bright. The only real downside I encountered is that a 35mm full frame cropping is not available. Even if this meant a white border were present it would be preferable to me to not have to crop my original image.
By alan
My puzzle order was shipped out within 24 hours, arrived quickly, and was beautiful. Highly recommend!
By Laura S.
Speed of order and delivery
By C O.
We chose a high resolution photo (that we had added words to, to make the 500 piece puzzle easier and now wish we had gone big with 1000 pieces instead) and we’re really impressed with the high resolution result. It came faster than promised, and really wowed the happy gift recipient. Will likely be making more puzzles for future gifts!
By Zac W.
I’m very disappointed in how long this is taking. According to the estimated delivery, it will have been 12 days in total since my order. Other than that, I have no idea how this puzzle will turn out until I receive it.
By heather H.
The service was prompt 5 star I bought these as gifts for two grandmothers keen on puzzles as Christmas gifts after reading on Reddit that these puzzles were well made. I won't know that until they are opened on Christmas day. However, the pictures on the lid of each puzzle are very dark compared to how the photos I used looked on my computer so I'm disappointed. If the puzzles turn out like the boxes I will buy from elsewhere next time in the hope of a better result.
By Wanda