Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
115 reviews
MakeYourPuzzlesSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are puzzlers and create happiness, one piece at a time!We know what puzzlers want and so we bring our know-how and expertise to the custom photo puzzle market - providing premium quality. MakeYourPuzzles is a brand that creates and distributes premium quality, yet affordable custom photo puzzles to puzzlers all over the world. From the traditional custom photo puzzles with 1 image to collage photo puzzles with up to 64 images - we got you covered!We believe in a future of endless possibilities, and we intend to take our customers on the journey of innovation and creativity through all our products.
MakeYourPuzzles (makeyourpuzzles.com) has 115 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
115 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Beautifully defined picture, not warped by the raised look around the cuts of pieces like some puzzles. We used our favorite picture from our wedding and it's been a joy and connecting experience to recognize people from that day by small parts of what they were wearing, a piece of the smiles on their faces, etc. Also hilarious to "put my mom together."
By SARAH W.
The website is easy to use. Uploading pictures is fast and easy. Being able to adjust the photos was quick and painless lol
By Corrine B.
Great quality. Speedy service, Sharp colors. Tight interlocking pieces. Frame worthy.
By Meme D.
I ordered my first custom puzzle from some landscape photos I had taken in Grand Tetons and Yellowstone National Parks. I'm very pleased. Good quality puzzle with pieces of all different shapes. Some of them quite unusual. This made for a cool experience putting the puzzle together that my wife and I really liked. It also arrived very quickly after ordering which surprised me. Being able to customize the box a bit was a nice touch too. I have only one minor suggestion. It's be nice to include a sheet in the box with the image printed on it to use as a guide. I find that a bit easier than using the picture on the box cover. I know that might be a slight up-charge, but maybe it could be a $1 add-on option or something when ordering. It's a minor thing though. Bottom Line is I loved it and no regrets at all.
By Bruce H.
My puzzle was beautiful! Clear and nice. I had some trouble negoating thru the process to order and order the box . So I actually ended up with 2 of the same puzzle. But glad I goofed cause I'm happy to get two, one for a gift and one for me!
By Janet
The puzzles I ordered look terrific and are great quality too!
By D L.
Easy process to order a custom puzzle. Quick production and delivered on time ... as promised. This is the second custom puzzle I have ordered and will order more in the future. I highly recommend their services.
By Jim Hines, SW F.
Puzzle arrived late but came in today. It is very nice.
By Helen C.
