Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
238 reviews
Huntington WatchSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We at Huntington Watch are a distinguished retailer of luxury pre-owned timepieces on Long Island. Our generations of experience allow us to offer a curated selection of high-end watches at competitive pricing. We strive to provide our customers at Huntington Watch with the pinnacle of care and satisfaction. So, whether online or at our in-person location, our expert staff is always on hand to assist you in finding the perfect watch.
Huntington Watch (huntingtonwatch.com) has 238 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
238 approved reviews, newest moderated first
This is the 7th Rolex watch I have purchased from Huntington watches. Every time Richard Allen tells me what he is going to do & does exactly as he says. Appraisals that come with a watch purchased from Huntington are required for insurance…much appreciated. I consider Richard to be a trusted advisor!!
By Brian W.
Great buying experience and communications with Richard. Watch was delivered overnight in the condition as advertised. Would highly recommend!
By Dr. Mark C.
I have said in my previous review, great company and trustworthy, this is my second rolex i bought in a span of two weeks, both were perfect and with full set. I am very happy and strongly recommend without any doubt they are great and legitimate in selling authentic Rolex watches with secure overnight deliveries.
By eli A.
Thanks Richard. Great watch. Made the transaction easy.
By Mark
Found the watch I was looking for on the Huntington watches website. Called first thing in the morning and talked with Chris. He promptly sent videos, pictures and describe the watch as mint condition with papers. After short considerations with couple calls to Chris, which he promptly answered, I confirmed Huntington business reputation and wired funds at 3 PM Friday. Watch arrived my home in Florida 1:30pm Saturday. Flawless experience, I would highly recommend Huntington watches.
By Clint B.
I traded a few watches for a Daytona. Had a wonderful and smooth experience with Rich. He was very helpful and was quite fair with the trade-ins.
By Andrew T.
Excellent communication. Overnight delivery of watch. Watch was perfectly packaged. A very easy process in buying a watch.
By PHILIP I.
They made the overall experience purchasing my first Rolex stress free. Their quality and pricing is unmatched. Looking forward to my next purchase.
By DENNIS C.
