Monday, November 2, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
238 reviews
Huntington WatchSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We at Huntington Watch are a distinguished retailer of luxury pre-owned timepieces on Long Island. Our generations of experience allow us to offer a curated selection of high-end watches at competitive pricing. We strive to provide our customers at Huntington Watch with the pinnacle of care and satisfaction. So, whether online or at our in-person location, our expert staff is always on hand to assist you in finding the perfect watch.
Huntington Watch (huntingtonwatch.com) has 238 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
238 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Huntington Watch Company delivered on a Mint condition 18238 grail watch! The sales person Richard helped me with a seamless sale and sizing of the watch before shipping it out. The price, condition, warranty, and incredible service all made this experience amazing. Go with Huntington Watch Company, you will be very happy.
By Michael J T.
I had been looking for this watch for about a year. There was a certain year, condition and a complete set that were a must. Huntington Watch had the exact watch. I called and worked with Chris who was stellar. He had several video calls with me showing me what I needed to see. When the watch arrived it was perfect and exactly as described. I highly recommended Huntington Watch and working with Chris. I have another watch I am looking for and check daily to see if they have one. Respectfully
By Rus S.
Smooth experience. Watch came as desribed. Everything happened quickly with no down time. Fair price great quality.
By Brian
I have done multiple transaction with Chris at Huntington and have been more than pleased each and every time. They are wonderful to deal with and I look forward to working with them again soon
By Alan Z.
Great store to do business with!
By Carlos G.
I had a wonderful experience with Huntington Watches! The team was fantastic to work with and took the time to answer every question I had. The watch arrived in exactly the mint condition they described, was carefully packed, and shipped overnight. On top of the excellent service, I honestly believe I got the best price around. I couldn’t be happier with the purchase and would highly recommend Huntington Watches to anyone looking for a great watch and a team they can trust!
By Nick R.
Richard is a great guy, and he always delivers as promised. He is fair priced on the watches, and when he sends it, you get it the next morning. And when he says it’s mint, it is mint. very happy.
By Erik F.
I had the pleasure of working with Richard, the owner the past couple weeks. Richard provided exceptional service on a Rolex Smurf watch, trading in my Rolex Blue Submariner. I sent my watch in, received the next day and my Smurf Rolex sent that same day for overnight delivery. Highly recommended for anyone considering purchasing from Huntington Watch.
By Jeff D.
