Love the shoes and the price!!
Love the shoes and the price!!! I wish they came with a cushion insert for a little better comfort!!! Great job they both look very nice, I got one brown and one black pair!!! Love them both!!!
By Bill C.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
1,396 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Over 250,000 happy customers!
Gatsbyshoes (gatsbyshoes.co) has 1,396 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.1 out of 5.
1,396 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Love the shoes and the price!!! I wish they came with a cushion insert for a little better comfort!!! Great job they both look very nice, I got one brown and one black pair!!! Love them both!!!
By Bill C.
A very good experience. App is east to use a d product arrived as expected. US size larger than CDN, but ok so far.
By sel F.
Light weight, comfortable and good looking. Received many compliments from strangers and referred them to Gatsby.
By Robert C.
Ordered the shoes for work. So far I love them my feet have been happy and I got 4 compliments the first day I wore them by total strangers. I walk a lot of miles with work at a major airline.
By Anthony V.
Bought 3 pairs of shoes,I exchange 2 wrong size never use.We love this shoes comfortable and very stylish!!I Email them next day they send me the instructions for return .We pay for shipping and the other 2 pairs there on there way. Doe’s how easy it was!!!
By Veronica N.
Great shoes, but would’ve liked a little more room in the tie box. Very stylish shoes and have received numerous compliments on their appearance.
By David G.
Very satisfied with the Gatsby purchases I have made over the past 12 months. Prompt delivery and really comfortable/classy shoes. Also, email follow-up and staff contact were professional and helpful. I also appreciate the informative emails I receive about product care.
By Vincent O.
These shoes are exceptionally nice looking and very comfortable. Good quality material. no complaints for me at all
By camlew