Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
42 reviews
The Holster MillSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Holster Mill focuses solely on the combination of high quality, and affordability. We NEED the highest quality holsters and we shouldn't have to break the budget to buy one. Every holster from The Holster Mill follows industry leading standards. Only .080 kydex is used for all IWB, and standard drop leg/competition holsters, .093 for all light duty rated drop leg holsters and .125 for all full/heavy duty drop leg level II retention holsters. If you were curious about about the logo, yes, The Holster Mill is a Faith Based brand.
The Holster Mill (theholstermill.com) has 42 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
42 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Always great quality and great customer service. The best part is they are a faith base company.
By Ross F.
Response from The Holster Mill· Nov 28, 2025
Thanks for taking time this holiday season to share your experience with others! We appreciate your support! Faith first!
Great service and Super Fast shipping! Thank you, I will be ordering more!
By Tony H.
Response from The Holster Mill· Oct 14, 2025
Thank you for taking time to share your experience with others! We look forward to working with you again in the future. Thank you again for choosing The Holster Mill!
Purchased a second holster for the CZ P-07, because the craftsmanship is there. This is my go to holster company ✨
By Gordon
Response from The Holster Mill· Oct 2, 2025
Thank you! Not only for purchasing with us again, but also for taking time to leave another review! We sincerely appreciate your loyalty and hope to earn your business again. Thank you for continuing to shop with The Holster Mill!
I recently purchased y first OBC, and I must say, I was blown away by its quality! It exceeded all my expectations. I’m already thinking about getting another one. Keep up the great work, and the customer service is also excellent.
By Sheldon R.
Response from The Holster Mill· Sep 7, 2025
Thank you for taking time to share your experience Sheldon. Very happy to hear your new OBC has exceeded your expectations! We hope to get a chance to work with you again in the future!
The KOTJ is a great quality product. Super adjustable, super comfortable, and super concealable even with a full sized firearm. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a new holster at an affordable price with reasonable wait times. The customer service is like no other!! Great job.
By Kary Horne J.
Response from The Holster Mill· Sep 6, 2025
Thank you for taking time to share your experience with others! Very happy to hear your feedback on The KOTJ! We hope to get an opportunity to work with you again in the future! Thank you again for choosing The Holster Mill!
Great communication on when my holster would be ready and delivered. Excellent product when I received it!
By Tyler M.
Response from The Holster Mill· Jul 24, 2025
Thank you taking time out of your day yo leave a review! Very happy to hear you are pleased with the communication and ultimately your holster! Hope to earn your business again in the future!
Really love the holster. Customer service is excellent. Gun and magazine fit really well. Definitely the most comfortable holster I have ever owned.
By Robert
Response from The Holster Mill· Jun 15, 2025
Ecstatic to hear you love your new holster! Thank you for taking time to continue to support The Holster Mill by leaving a review! Hope to get a chance to work with you again in the future!
Very responsive. The quality of the holster is fantastic. I could not be happier with the fit and finish along with the comfort.
By Travis W.
Response from The Holster Mill· May 2, 2025
Thanks for taking time to leave a review to further support The Holster Mill. Hope to get a chance to work with you in the future!
