Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
42 reviews
The Holster MillSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Holster Mill focuses solely on the combination of high quality, and affordability. We NEED the highest quality holsters and we shouldn't have to break the budget to buy one. Every holster from The Holster Mill follows industry leading standards. Only .080 kydex is used for all IWB, and standard drop leg/competition holsters, .093 for all light duty rated drop leg holsters and .125 for all full/heavy duty drop leg level II retention holsters. If you were curious about about the logo, yes, The Holster Mill is a Faith Based brand.
The Holster Mill (theholstermill.com) has 42 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Showing 3 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters
Product is great. The lead time and communication was 1 star.
By William W.
Response from The Holster Mill· Jul 13, 2026
We appreciate yhe honest review! We've made some substantial changes since your order and can assure this will not be a problem in the future. We hope to work with you again!
Well it's hard to make a review when I haven't gotten the thing yet. I would've went with a more reliable company, but since I got a bit of an odd ball (Canik mete SF, W/Olight PL-X) no one makes a holster for it. When I first made my order; it had a 10-15 day lead time. Now it's week 4, and not a peep from the seller. I tried contacting through the website. Nothing. Tried through a email. Nothing. I understand if there's delays, (annoying but understandable) but at least tell me it's delayed or something. Don't just leave me in the dark. At this point it just seems like a scam site. I hope I'm wrong, but we'll see. I'll probably change my review if I ever receive it. *Edit 06/30/26*: Now it's week 6, and still no holster. I actually did get a shipping update on my order saying the labe was created, and is awaiting pick up. That was weeks ago, and it still hasn't left. It's being shipped out of Florida, and I live just one state over. So at this point I could have just driven to Florida, and picked it up myself; and it would have been faster. The seller did actually contact me after my last review, and was very apologetic for the delay; and lack of communication. Saying they never got my emails, and this kind of thing has happened before. I tried to respond back, and got nothing again. I'll update again if I ever get my holster. *Edit 07/14/27* I finally got my holster! From the time I ordered it (May 16th). To the time I got it (July 7th) it was a total of 7½ weeks. That's a long time for anything let alone a holster; but now that I have it. It's time for an actual review of it. **The Real Review** So right off the back it's a pretty good holster. It feels quality; and is nice and sturdy. It's the DPC+ (Light Bearing), and it's great. The only thing I wish it had was the ability to cant both ways instead of the just the one. One of the edges looked a bit unfinished, but it wasn't sharp or uncomfortable at all. So overall I'd give the site 3/5. 2/5 for the overall shipping process, and 3.5/5 for the holster The shipping process is really holding the company back from being a great option, but hopefully they'll make changes and get there.
By Tyler S.
Ordered the DCP+ on February 20- at which point lead time was 7-10 days. Finally received the holster on April 4 after some obvious delays and miscommunications. The holster itself looks great!!! The cordura covering adds a level of comfort without adding any additional thickness. Innovative belt clip apparatus adds more adjustability rather than the clip being attached directly to the holster. The guys did offer a refund at a point in the process to try and make it right. Based on the cordura option alone I WOULD want to get another holster, but i am wary of delays.
By Benjamin C.
Response from The Holster Mill· May 21, 2026
We appreciate your honest review and apologize for the extreme delays you suffered during the process. We've just passed our 1 year mark and have surely experienced some growing pains. We hope for a chance at your business in the future and can assure than you don't experience a wait like this in the future.
