Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
59 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The official memorabilia provider of the New York Yankees, New York Knicks, Derek Jeter, Odell Beckham Jr., New York Rangers and more! Authenticity Guaranteed!
Steiner Sports (steinersports.com) has 59 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
59 approved reviews, newest moderated first
My Autographed Mookie Betts Photo got caught in The Great Snow Storm of February 2021. But not for long! Tyler from Steiner S was on the job from day 1. He tracked it down like a Bloodhound! Got Fedex to send it to me overnight. Got it the next day since I paid for overnight. Steiner is a little more expensive but they've definitely got their stuff together!
By Randy L.
Tyler was fantastic to deal with- He communicated all the way through the process. I wish every company had a person like him..
By Richard P.
My package was lost by FedEx. I contacted Steiner and Tyler got in touch with me and was great. He filed the lost item claim with FedEx and kept me up to date. Couldn't be any happier with Tyler's service.
By Matthew Y.
Donna was an absolute joy to work with! Everything was taken care of with ease, and Donna communicated well every step of the way! Top notch customer service!
By Bryan
Recently, I purchased a jersey frame from Steiner Sports but my office delivery details were incomplete. Once I called Steiner Sports, I luckily spoke to one of their employees named Cristin and she was absolutely fantastic! Cristin was very personable, proactive and helpful in locating my package and connecting with the courier to ensure that any further delay in delivery was avoided. I actually received the package within 24 hours after our call! Once Cristin talked to the courier, she called me back and sent me an email to assist in managing my expectations and that she did! I will certainly think of Steiner Sports for any future sports related purchases and I give much of that credit to the service I received from Cristin. Great job!
By Ryan
Shelby provided me excellent service in helping me determine if my signed baseball was authentic, which it was. Very helpful for sure.
By Adam S.
Cristin helped me out with all my concerns in regards to shipping and authenticity of my signed Brian Urlacher photo! With her kindness and professionalism I will definitely be referring back to her for all my future purchases. Regardless what shes paid she deserves a raise
By Joshua C.
Cristin provided me with excellent customer service! I called after receiving an incorrect item and the correct one was sent to me immediately. I received a return label and instructions for returning the incorrect item. I am very happy and I know my grandson will be too. I will continue shopping at Steinersports.com!
By David G.
