Had the chance to meet Brandon Steiner…
Had the chance to meet Brandon Steiner personally and got a few truly amazing memorabilia from Steiner Sports. Class act and great products all the way!
By Jerry C.
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
59 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The official memorabilia provider of the New York Yankees, New York Knicks, Derek Jeter, Odell Beckham Jr., New York Rangers and more! Authenticity Guaranteed!
Steiner Sports (steinersports.com) has 59 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
59 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Had the chance to meet Brandon Steiner personally and got a few truly amazing memorabilia from Steiner Sports. Class act and great products all the way!
By Jerry C.
Twice Steiner Sports listed a Wembanyama wings signed Alien autographed picture on Ebay. I ordered once in November 2025, then they said it was not in their inventory. It was listed again in December 2025, and I ordered it again. I was just informed that the item is not in their inventory again and they canceled my order. It is a $7,500 item. You would think they would know something that expensive is in their inventory. I can understand once, but not twice. Both times they offered me 10% off another item. Do not order from this company. They either don't know what they are doing, or just trying to get you to buy another item.
By Lawrence S.
The due date arrived and the order was still processing. This was a retirement gift and I paid extra for the two day delivery. Attempted to contact them to see what was going on, but no way to reach them. Several ways listed, but no answer no chat available, like advertised.
By J. G.
the stuff is not what's advertised on the website they create images and pictures to make it look much better, mine was filthy unusable no way to frame it stained torn writing.... They represent picture of a brand new shirt, and then ship one that's been destroyed rolled in the mud
By Bradley B.
$1000.00 order Sept. 26th and still hasn't arrived. This was for a birthday that has long passed. I can not get ahold of them in any way shape or form. Horrible Company
By AJ C.
Horrible customer service says wait time 30 seconds BS. Returned damaged item and 2 months later still not refund. Never Never Never buy from Steiner or Fanatics (same company)
By Mac
RUTH, Was awesome and took care of the mixup quickly and efficiently. She was very pleasant to work with
By Mark
Josh provided me great service and assisted me with my order in a kind manner. Super helpful.
By Ronnie