Got exactly what I wanted
Got exactly what I wanted, in a timely fashion, from my son’s pin wish list.
By David L.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
147 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Your trusted source for Pinny Arcade pins.
Pinnyshop (pinnyshop.com) has 147 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
147 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Got exactly what I wanted, in a timely fashion, from my son’s pin wish list.
By David L.
I was so happy to see the selection of pins, especially because I thought I missed out on these and now I have some of the key ones I wanted. Great condition, packaging, and worth the price when they’re hard to get ones in good condition.
By Juan Rolon J.
Nice and fast all the pins came in good condition
By Emily
I've ordered may times from pinny shop and it's always been a great experience. Shipping is always fast and the pins always arrive undamaged. The first time I ordered I was unaware that I was only $5 away from free shipping. The owner messaged me directly saying he was including a extra $5 pin for free. The customer service is spectacular and I look forward to buying from them for years to come.
By Andrew
Great and responsive cx, intl. postage feels a little sluggish
By NICHOLAS
Super fast shipping and the pin was in great condition :)
By DOGMA
Service was grate and they helped me out a lot by answering questions and getting my order out to me.
By Kaz
Like being able to sort and find what I needed to fill in my collection and shipping was super fast.
By Elizabeth