Great selection
Great selection. Easy check out and shipping. Arrived quickly and in great condition. Will be purchasing again.
By Alexander M.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
147 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Your trusted source for Pinny Arcade pins.
Pinnyshop (pinnyshop.com) has 147 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
147 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Great selection. Easy check out and shipping. Arrived quickly and in great condition. Will be purchasing again.
By Alexander M.
The seller’s communication was great. He let me know there would be a delay promptly, and when he did send them, the pins arrived promptly.
By Michael P.
Good value.
By James F.
Fast delivery, great value
By UnicornHarrison
The pins were promptly shipped!
By Maia
What made my experience great started with a misunderstanding; I reached out, and the owner of the business realized that the system had marked my order as complete, when it never left. We got it all sorted out, and my order arrived less than a week later. All's well that ends well!
By Erin N.
Great delivery. Great transaction overall.
By Brandon S.
Original-Came way later than expected, was told this item was going to come in April, but didn't show up until Mid may. Update: This was a, 'my bad' review on my end so I apologize! I had ordered through a different site at the same time and they were the slowpokes, not you guys! Thanks for understanding. You guys were awesome, seriously. A mistake on my end and you fixed it. I appreciate you! Will purchase from again!
By Stephanie
Response from Pinnyshop· May 20, 2025
Hi Stephanie. I'm sorry the order was delayed. When I look at our record, the order was placed at 8:20pm on 4/24/25. The package was picked up by the post office the following day. The tracking showed a status of "insufficient address" on 4/26/25. The package was successfully delivered on 5/3/25 at 11am. You had brought it to our attention the address was incorrectly entered at checkout and that the package was being mailed back to us. At that point, we shipped a replacement package that was delivered on 5/1/25. Both packages were delivered. I believe this was outside of our control but I do apologize it affected your experience with us.