PinnyshopReviews of pinnyshop.com

Pinnyshop reviews

147 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Apr 20, 2026
Fast shipping and great selection
Fast shipping and great selection
By Matt H.
Report
Apr 13, 2026
Was easy to order and get the pins.
Was easy to order and get the pins.
By Eric H.
Report
Apr 13, 2026
Great customer service
Ordered pin fodder while at PAX East, expecting to use it for the next convention. I was contacted by a staff member who was at the convention and I was able to recieve my fodder AT the con. Great service, would recommend.
By Michelle
Report
Apr 5, 2026
Quick fast
Quick fast. Product as expected.
By Doiri
Report
Apr 1, 2026
Speedy shipping
Speedy shipping
By Zansake
Report
Mar 30, 2026
Blind Buy Fodder
My order came super fast and all the fodder pins were in excellent condition, perfect for trading at PAX. I would definitely use this option again in the future!
By Madi S.
Report
Mar 25, 2026
As expected the PinnyShop exceeds…
As expected the PinnyShop exceeds expectations! The quality and selection is unmatched and you know you will get what you bought for a very fair price. They always deliver and will respond to questions and concern quickly and professionally. I have been a customer for about 6 or more years and dont bother looking elsewhere!
By Patrick L.
Report
Mar 18, 2026
Once again Eric is a Rockstar
Once again Eric is a Rockstar. My Pins came quick and exactly what I ordered. Great customer service. Will be buying from again in the future!
By Rita S.
Report