Wednesday, November 4, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
222 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The largest selection of custom jewelry designs and rare gemstones. All created in house. Family owned. Located in northwest Indiana near Chicago.
Moriarty's Gem Art (moregems.com) has 222 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
222 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I love my new tanzanite pendant! The raw tanzanite is incredibly gemmy with lovely rainbows that catch the light. The tanzanite looks great wrapped in sterling silver wire. I'm happy I could get this item on sale. I get compliments each time I wear it. This is my 2nd order from this store. I appreciate that order arrive quickly and securely packaged. Thank you!
By Mindy C.
I was very pleased with the items I purchase from the Estate Jewelry. It was exactly has described and each piece was stunning and unique!
By customer
All good. Love the ring.
By Ron H.
I love my ring! The stones are excellent. The quality is the best. I would not hesitate getting a piece of jewelry custom made from Moriarty Gems. Very happy with the whole process!
By Julie
As always the professionalism stands out in the offerings & customer service. Purchased 22K gold small sapphire dangle earring. Well packaged. (Suggestion, when you need to reorder small jewelry boxes, think about an upgrade. Currently the ones I have gotten look like their from the 50's. Presentation isn't everything, but I won't use these to gift.)
By Richard T.
I purchased 2 color change garnets and worked with Alice to have them set in a ring in platinum. Gorgeous!
By Lynn Camden P.
Beautiful blue zircon at a fantastic price. Quick shipping and great communication / service. Thank you!
By Jacob V.
I am so excited that I had custom made, a heliodor-yellow beryl gents ring. Its beautiful. My dream came true.. since middle School I wanted a yellow beryl ring. I remember reading about, heliodor in six grade. Now I finally own this amazing well done beryl ring.
By C W.