Fake jellycats!!
Fake jellycats sent despite using official jellycat pictures to advertise them. Will be reporting to Trading Standards
By EC
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Bad
42 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Welcome to Mayfair Plush Company, your destination for delightful plushies and heartfelt gifts! We specialize in curating a collection of the most popular, huggable plushies and unique treasures that bring joy to every moment.
Mayfairplushcompany (mayfairplushcompany.com) has 42 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 1.7 out of 5.
42 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Fake jellycats sent despite using official jellycat pictures to advertise them. Will be reporting to Trading Standards
By EC
Items are fake, stay away from this company. Please becareful of this site
By Katie and H.
I thought these were genuine jellycats but they are not. So overpriced fakes!
By Paula O.
Items arrived quickly but tags do not match the items! Emailed for a response. Lolly sugarglider is labelled as sad rat Timmy turtle is labeled as sad doll Would not buy again!
By Samantha B.
Never received my order #1122, have since learnt they come from China (probably fake as per other reviews). tracking shows airport issues, customs issues, import issues, & delivered
By Paul A.
They are not jelly cats cheap fakes dont waste your money they are coming from china
By Christine K.
I’ve had an email to say my order was delivered yet I don’t have it! It’s a birthday gift so more than disappointed. I’ve no evidence of delivery or response from this company regarding this order and supposed delivery. Very disappointing experience and service as I’m left without the item I paid for!
By Bea
Not original jellycat and the return address is china so do not order Would have send to off and cost more than the refund
By Mark H.