I guess they're mine now
Beautiful earrings but they were too heavy for my ears. Unfortunately, I didn't realize before ordering that they couldn't be returned.
By Katherine
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Poor
114 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Heaven Mayhem is an accessory and lifestyle brand celebrated for its refined, wearable statements that elevate the everyday. Rooted in timeless design and reimagined for the modern wardrobe, each piece is developed with our community in mind.
Heaven Mayhem (heavenmayhem.com) has 114 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 2.0 out of 5.
114 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Beautiful earrings but they were too heavy for my ears. Unfortunately, I didn't realize before ordering that they couldn't be returned.
By Katherine
Beautiful items and amazing customer service.
By Molly
I made a purchase online with Heaven Mayham. I bought 5 pairs of earrings, spent about $500. When I received my order I couldn’t believe my eyes. Generic boxes,cheap,low quality, heavy, damaged, garbage! I reached out to the company and it turns out no refunds on earrings! I wonder why? This company is a scam. You can buy BETTER earrings on Amazon for $10 a pair. The most disappointing, embarrassing, experience!
By Cyndi Van H.
Response from Heaven Mayhem· Jun 12, 2026
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We're very sorry to hear that your order did not meet your expectations. We never want a customer to receive items that arrive damaged. If any of the earrings arrived with defects or damage, our team would be happy to review the issue and work toward a resolution. Regarding returns, earrings are eligible for return; however, for hygiene reasons, they are only eligible for exchange or store credit. This policy is listed on our product pages and within our return policy. We understand that not everyone will love our products, and we're sorry to hear that was your experience. If you're willing, please reach out to our Customer Support team and mention your Trustpilot review so we can take a closer look at your order and any quality concerns you experienced. Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback.
I had a very disappointing experience with Heaven Mayhem. I placed my order in February 2026, and for an entire month there were no updates or changes to the order status. Only after I contacted them myself did I find out there were “shipping issues” and that my item was actually out of stock. Instead of informing me earlier, they waited until I reached out and then issued a refund. Waiting that long with no communication is frustrating and concerning. Customers deserve transparency, especially if an order cannot be fulfilled. Overall, this experience felt unprofessional and a bit suspicious to me.
By Rrita
Response from Heaven Mayhem· Jun 12, 2026
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We completely understand why you were frustrated by the lack of updates and apologize for the experience. We ship thousands of orders each week and work hard to monitor every shipment, but occasionally an order can fall through the cracks, especially during particularly busy periods. While that is never our intention, we understand that doesn't make the experience any less disappointing. We want to assure you that there was nothing suspicious about your order. Once you reached out, our team investigated the issue, identified the problem, and issued a refund when we determined we could not fulfill the order as expected. We appreciate you advocating for yourself and bringing the issue to our attention so we could resolve it. While we understand your disappointment, we hope you'll consider updating your review to reflect that a resolution was provided once the issue was identified. Thank you again for your feedback.
Items tarnish easily, stones of earrings fall and on top of all that they take weeks to ship orders with customer service not helping at all. Do not order.
By Rachel
The jewelry valu and price. Variety on jewelry and other items. The presentation of the items being shown to the visiting customers.
By Anselmo Ortiz A.
Bought a few pieces (clove earrings, prize earrings, baby knot earrings) when I saw the pieces on a co-worker. They are all great quality and came in a timely manner. I also received a Saie lip liner as a gift with purchase that is now my favorite. 10/10 would recommend.
By Nicole
Amazing experince buying from this company. Exceptional customer Service. Quality products
By jen