Good Sticks delivered
Good Sticks delivered. Enjoyed trying the La Polina "The Relativity" for the first time. Though oily dark, it was very smooth with notes of dark chocolate and coffee
By Julio
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
257 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
CigarClub is a cigar membership and gift shop that handpicks cigars for you based on your taste preferences.
CigarClub (cigarclub.com) has 257 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
257 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Good Sticks delivered. Enjoyed trying the La Polina "The Relativity" for the first time. Though oily dark, it was very smooth with notes of dark chocolate and coffee
By Julio
Great quality cigars love the website
By Shalecia
Love the idea of someone handpicking my monthly subscription based on my flavor profile. I have NOT been disappointed so far......even smoked a few brands that I've stayed away from because of a bad stick. But they've even taken those brands and found something I can say I like from them. Awesome customer service(the best IMO), very personable with their members, and quick to answer any question you may have. Well with the money with either subscription.
By Heath
Awesome choices!
By Scott
Prompt service , decent picks
By Steve
The mild and mild medium were excellent! The bold flavor was ok, but I’m not much of a bold guy.
By Dean
I have now had 2 of the 3 cigars from my first box. I can't even begin to say how bang on they have got my taste profile!. they are next to if not perfect. cigarclub is the only place I will trust my cigars with.. once they get the shipping to Canada fixed I will increase my subscription to monthly
By Jeff
Cigar Club has an incredibly unique formula that matched my taste to new cigars perfectly! I love the special treat that comes in the box every month too!
By Elizabeth