Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
101 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
WizardPins offers high-quality custom pins, custom coins, custom keychains and more. Unlimited art revisions, free shipping & 100% custom.
Wizard Pins (wizardpins.com) has 101 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
101 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Everything was perfect. From the first interaction, through the proof process, to the shipping and final product. They stayed in touch at every step making sure I got what I needed and when. I anticipate we'll be using Wizard Pins again very soon.
By Dana P.
I worked with them to produce a pin of our schools mascot. They were easy to communicate with, their artists were talented and listened, and the pins came out looking beautiful! We even had them include a small print of our logo on the back and it has some fine details in it, and even that came out looking great! Highly recommend working with them.
By Andrew
The item we ordered was beyond our expectations. Simply beautifully crafted. Very attentive and fast customer service and happy to finesse any minute requests! Please order from this company, people like these here are hard to find.
By Celine P.
Smooth transaction! Super fast responses! Great quality product! Will order again!
By Tiffany L.
I love Wizard Pins! Not only are the products great—the team went above and beyond to make sure a rush order arrived in time for an event.
By Amanda S.
We had pins created to honor our volunteer team's service, and they turned out amazing! Steve was so helpful and responsive during the entire process. Our team even shed a team when we unboxed them for the first time.
By Hannah C.
Love love love them! I made a fun AI pin on my phone and we posted on my chef page and it was so well received we decided to buy some and see what happens. I sent in a snap shot what I made on my and they duplicates it. *mind blown* We got them today and they look exactly like the photo. Thank you so much!!!
By Chef A.
Wizard Pins went above and beyond normal business communications to assure speedy production of my pin order and a rush Fedex one-day delivery. When Fedex failed to deliver on time, Wizard responded immediately and rushed a new delivery to my conference destination, assuring I had my pins. The ease of ordering, designing, and producing with personalized service assures I'll be continuing to use the service and recommending Wizard to others.
By Jack M.
