Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
663 reviews
Uncommon GoodsSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Uncommon Goods is listed under Wedding & Party in Brooklyn, New York.
Uncommon Goods (uncommongoods.com) has 663 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.9 out of 5.
Showing 32 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
No problem with Uncommon Goods or their products. I have a problem with OnTrac who they contract delivery with. Packages not delivered to the house, left outside in the dirt. Won’t buy from Uncommon Goods until they change their delivery service.
By Genevieve R.
Uncommon Goods offers many unique, artisan-made items I don’t see other places. The downside is their products are very expensive, I mean very expensive. That said, I do love gifting their items, because the receiver probably doesn’t have anything quite like what I’m sending from Uncommon Goods.
By Amy
Plenty of interesting merchandise to view many unique items not found elsewhere
By Paul Reitnauer J.
Love the products and they were delivered on time.
By Betty
I always worry about fragile items but uncommon goods packages them very safely. The products do look better in photos than reality though.
By Jan S.
Cereal product contained rock hard raisins. I contacted support (Alanna) to let them know not expecting anything in return. Although it wasn’t said, I expect that this problem will be investigated and corrected.
By customer
Response from Uncommon Goods· Oct 23, 2025
Thanks for taking the time to post a review. We think you may have intended this for a different business. Uncommon Goods does not sell cereal but we do have some delicious (and fresh!) treats.
Good experience. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is because of the shipping expense. True, you can not get "uncommon goods" at Amazon, Wal-mart, or other websites but even at these other places if you spend a certain amount the shipping becomes free! I realize with uncommon perks I could have gotten free shipping, nevertheless, at the other webites I also don't have Prime, or +, or subscriptions, etc either. Thought I would let buyers know. So, yeah, good experience. It would have been Great or Excellent if the shipping were free with the $140-something (not including tax or shipping) I paid for when I bought the two items.
By Sarabeth
Love them for “not mainstream” gifts
By Customer
