Good service provider
I have a good shopping experience with this site! Keep up the good work!
By Nancy
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
663 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Uncommon Goods is listed under Wedding & Party in Brooklyn, New York.
Uncommon Goods (uncommongoods.com) has 663 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.9 out of 5.
Showing 32 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters
I have a good shopping experience with this site! Keep up the good work!
By Nancy
I ordered monogrammed ornaments. They said I would have the proofs in 1-2 business days. It took over a week to get the proofs. The proofs looked good, but I haven't seen the final product yet to give an opinion on them. I had chatted with Uncommon Goods and they were very kind in telling me there was a backlog on getting the proofs out.
By Susan M.
I had a problem with my order,not knowing whether it was received or not. It was taken over by the person I talked and I received it today in time. I like your products and I have very few problems with your company. You have fun products.
By Ronald M.
Overall great experience!
By Margaret T.
I'm torn on this one. The products are good - if quite expensive - but this year has been a challenge. The cons - they have no idea how to reach the actual sellers of the products they curate. I ordered a customized offering which had very specific delivery options, only to see the expected delivery fluctuate wildly in their status page. The pros - customer care really was excellent, even if they couldn't do any thing for me. Repeated promises for a manager phone call never materialized, but the agents answered promptly and seemed genuinely interested in my issue. The base issue - while the website was reporting a delivery date weeks in the future, it actually arrived a day earlier than originally promised. Not sure what to make of that one. Happy in the end, too much anxiety leading up to it.
By Colin
The item I ordered arrived on time with nice packaging. A bit pricy but worth it.
By Will
I have been a customer since 2016. Their service has tanked this year. I ordered two items that never got to me. The customer service department seems to not have a clue what you are asking for. I asked twice for a replacement gift card for my niece and I never got it. Barnes and Nobles will be getting my business instead. Update: after emailing customer service they reviewed the calls and apologized for the miscommunication. The are sending a gift certificate. I do appreciate the follow up and you can’t beat the mission of Uncommongoods.
By Lorene A.
Response from Uncommon Goods· Dec 22, 2019
We're really sorry about this, Lorene. We'd love to look into this. Would you mind sharing your full name, email address, or order number with us so we can see what happened here? We can be reached at [email protected]
Great product but I had to call to get the explanation card for the Glass Ceiling necklace.
By Connie O.