Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
323 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Heather Yunger didn't take a typical path into the culinary world, it came mostly out of a crazy (but effective) superstition. A superstition for her beloved Boston Bruins meant bringing her signature cookie, Black & Golds, for every home game.
Top Shelf Cookies (topshelfcookies.com) has 323 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
323 approved reviews, newest moderated first
We just received our second shipment of the Cookie of the Month Club subscription. The cookies are delicious in a somewhat unique way. The flavor of the cookie is to be savored by eating slowly. It is not overwhelmingly sweet which we appreciate.
By Debra & J.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Feb 4, 2022
So glad that you enjoyed, we really try to focus on the flavor as opposed to the sweetness!
The cookies are delicious and we are really enjoying the new recipes - pumpkin was hard to top but oaty fudge is a really good cookie!
By Jake In D.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
Thanks so much for taking the time to leave us a review. We are excited to keep sharing new recipes to our COTM subscribers.
Sent some of the Black and Golds and Alex’s Sweet Heat as a gift to friends, and they absolutely loved them. (As expected). Top Shelf Cookies is just that - a Top Shelf Product.
By Repeat C.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
Thank you so much for your orders and for taking the time to leave us a nice review!!
Great cookies and service. Thank you!!
By Y. L.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 27, 2022
Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a nice review. We appreciate your order!
The cookies were delicious and the packaging was great, not one broken cookie!! My son absolutely loved every bite!! Thank you so much!
By Beth Della R.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a kind review! We hope your son will continue to enjoy his cookies every month!
Great options and so delicious
By Roxanne V.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
Thanks for taking the time to leave us a nice review. We are so glad you are enjoying your Cookie of the Month!
This is a wonderful service. I had a little trouble getting exactly what I wanted and received several emails and follow ups to clarify. Great service and my niece in college says the cookies are fabulous.
By Jeffrey
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
Sorry it was a little bumpy to start, we're working on that part of it, we are better cookie bakers than computer programmers, we are thankful for your patience
My just-turned-16, hard-to-buy-for grandson thought this was a really cool gift. He has a sweet tooth so I’d be surprised if they lasted more than 24 hours though. The box arrived on time for his birthday…
By Katharine R.
Response from Top Shelf Cookies· Jan 30, 2022
We love when this is a hit for the hard to buy for person. Thanks for your support of our small business!
