Thursday, November 5, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
55 reviews
Brown Butter BakerSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Brown Butter Baker is an online bakery specializing in cookies for all occasions. We offer a variety of flavors including chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, sprinkles, white chocolate macadamia, cookies n' cream, and more. We offer nationwide shipping and catering services. All orders are baked fresh. Please visit us at www.brownbutterbaker.com.
Brown Butter Baker (brown-butter-baker.square.site) has 55 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
55 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The cookies arrived in good time and very well packaged. I wasn't sure because i've not bought cookies online much.But these cookies were so soft.I never had to remicrow them. They were chewy and most of all delicious. I have told all my family about them and sent them the website to order as well. I plan to reorder. I ordered the double chocolate chip cookie with peacons. But they're sold out right now.So I have to wait!
By Angela Davis J.
told myself I was only ordering one bag… now Brown Butter Baker is basically a monthly subscription I accidentally signed up for. Shipping is always quick, the packaging is adorable, and the cookies are AMAZING. The monthly flavors get me every single time.
By Jordan C.
amazing to cook with it
By Customer
OMG! Brown Butter Baker has two new flavors that she is trying out. Banana Nut and Dark Chocolate Pistachio. Let me tell you, these two cookies DO NOT disappoint!🍪🔥🍪
By Stephanie M.
The cookie was well baked, tasted like it was made by a professional baker.
By Kalkidan A.
It’s so good thank you for giving my mom this cookies for us
By Edla H.
10/10. Recommended 💯!
By Ale A.
I had tried the cookies and cream flavor and it was ‘🔥’ 5/5 will eat again. 🍪
By Raul R.
