Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
528 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
stoveguard.com is listed under Furniture Stores.
stoveguard.com (stoveguard.com) has 528 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.4 out of 5.
Showing 156 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
I received the Stove Guard Premium. It was a great fit and seemed perfect. The first time I used it, it melted in 2 places. I previously purchased the Lite, and it worked great for years. I’m hoping to get a replacement.
By Denise Jones E.
I am not happy with the product; it is in three sections and I assumed it would be one sheet of protective lining as the picture showed. Also, the fit is not exact so there is some buckling. It does not lay completely flat. Since it did not arrive damaged I am not eligible to return it under the company’s terms. Had I known this I would not have placed the order.
By Joseph M.
Improper use of the term express shipping. Express shipping does not ever include 3-day select nor take 3 days to ship worst customer service ever
By James M.
It’s very disappointing in that it allows grease to seep under the product resulting in double cleaning. Instead of cleaning the range top you now how to clean the cover and STILL clean the range top. It may protect from a heavy spill like spaghetti sauce or something similar, but normal everyday cooking it causes more work not less. It turns out to be a useless purchase
By customer
This is my 2nd purchase, the first one was a thicker material and lasted a long time, only reason I had to replace it was because after washing it was crumpled around the burner and got burnt but the new one is very thin and started to burn close to burner within first week
By Arvinder P.
I cut up into four pieces, it so flimsy and wasn't a good fit.
By Barbara M.
I originally gave stoveguard five stars, but after they sent me an email that I could purchase the same one I originally ordered for less than half price than lucky to get one star. I know I can return mine and reorder but after all the fees and not covering shipping- it’s not worth the hassle and trouble just to get the best price. The wife is happy with it and I have been talking about how nice it is with all my friends and family with gas cooktops- don’t think I will be doing that anymore. Sorry but not so happy customer.
By Van S.
I placed unit on my stove. I thought it was kind of thin. I made a small pot of soup. Went to clean, wipe it all clean and notice that it was scorched and wavy. This surely is a defect. I wish to return for a refund
By Debi
