The stove guard just isn't worth $120
The stove guard just isn't worth $120. It doesn't even lay completely flat on my stove. I'm very disappointed.
By Cherie F.
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
528 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
stoveguard.com is listed under Furniture Stores.
stoveguard.com (stoveguard.com) has 528 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.4 out of 5.
Showing 50 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters
The stove guard just isn't worth $120. It doesn't even lay completely flat on my stove. I'm very disappointed.
By Cherie F.
Good product but to much money will not buy another one
By Glenn W.
I had purchased a new stove and knew that I needed to protect it ASAP! I called your company because the price of $109.00 was out of my budget. I was told that usually during Memorial Day there is a sale. I checked daily, but no sale, June came and prices actually went up by $10.00, so I bite the bullet and ordered, since the substitute was so chintzy I had to return it. After I placed my orrder wtih Stove Guard I then noticed your barbaque give away. Grrrrr, so frustrating, and feeling like I have been dupped...... ORDER #SG-SPFY-560582 Thank you, Karen Johnson
By karen
The guard does not fit my cooktop. Way too long.
By Cheryl D.
This product is thin and feel cheap. It does not meet my expectations at this price point. The cutting is perfectly fitted my stove.
By Eric
The burner cutouts are larger than I anticipated. Most of the grease is build up around the burner, especially the area not covered.
By Sudhanshu N.
The guard arrived folded in a manner that it wouldn’t lie flat on the stove. We had to put heavy books on it to be flat enough to place on our stove
By Cindy K.
The mat seems durable but it has a bend and won’t lay flat.
By Steve B.