Courteous and professional service.
Courteous and professional service.
By John H.
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
149 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Your online seafood market. Natural, fresh wild salmon and seafood delivery. Order lobster, salmon, shrimp, scallops, cod, crab cakes and more!
Sizzlefish (sizzlefish.com) has 149 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
149 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Courteous and professional service.
By John H.
You have a great product. Plus, I had a problem with my order, and even though I made the mistake, you fixed it to my benefit. Great customer service!
By B S.
My initial order was really good. My next one was not. The king salmon fillets on the second order seemed older or just not as fresh as the first order. I will rethink future orders.
By Rita K.
Very easy to order, execllent qualty fish and received it 72 hours after ordering, it cant get much better than that!
By kenc
It never fails....the products are always delicious and fresh.
By Ophelia I.
I ordered shrimp, scallops, Faroe Island Salmon, lobster tails and "sushi quality" tuna. One shrimp bag was not sealed, the scallops were delicious as was the salmon. The lobster tails were sealed but not vacuum sealed. I was told by their chat bot that the tails were still good. After broiling, each tail had about 3-4 bites of meat. The flavor was just ok. The tuna? Horrible! It looked like it had color added. I'm a sushi eater and I have never seen sushi tuna that color. I seared it to a raw center and couldn't cut into it. It was as tough as a well done steak, chewy and very fishy. Even though the salmon and scallops were good, the other items were disappointing enough to make me not order from them again.
By Anne R.
The order was accurate. The salmon and tuna are delicious. We received the package within days of the requested delivery date. Everything was frozen solid.
By Christian F.
Love the service
By Nicole W.