Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
473 reviews
Signature CoinsSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
If you are looking for a custom challenge coin service that creates high quality coins in a short turnaround time, your search ends at Signature Coins. Here, you will get the widest range of challenge coins, challenge coin styles and custom coin designs. Get your free artwork and designs at signaturecoins.com today!
Signature Coins (signaturecoins.com) has 473 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
473 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Great company to do business with. From concept, to design, to final proofs to shipping it was about 6 weeks, the first couple weeks were design ideas and changes. The staff is wonderful with the design changes and even ideas. Shipping is free folks... cant beat that price!
By David A.
They do such an amazing job creating the coins exactly like I want them. Thank you for such great customer service!! You al are the best!!!
By Triple F Female F.
This is my second order with Signature Coins and I have only good things to say about everything related to our interaction. They are responsive to questions with clear information and suggestions. The preview images are clear and well defined. The finished product is beautiful and delivery is timely. Can't ask for much more.
By LTC-R Steve M.
The team made multiple revisions to make the coin exactly how I wanted them to be. Their customer service is top notch
By Martin T.
Jeff was great to work with. Provided proofs and pricing quickly.
By Mary Beth D.
Our group is very excited about having a custom coin for our members. Both Jeff and Eli were really helpful and made the process very simple. First time designing a coin, and I was a bit nervous. Great suggestions that improved the design. Looking forward to working with them in the future. UPDATE - I got my tracking number today - coins arrive 4/15 - I just ordered less than 2 weeks ago - 2 sided full color. Can't wait to see them - really awesome service - thanks!
By Committee of Ninety-nine C G.
Cheap, easy and fast. 2nd time working with these guys and will be working with them a third time shortly. They make the experience simple, and turn out a great product you wont regret.
By CPT J.
They worked very hard to created the perfect challenge coin that we envisioned. They worked very closely with us on edits and were very helpful.
By Amanda N.
