Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
190 reviews
Shirt MysterySelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are the most affordable destination for high-quality mystery football shirts from clubs and national teams around the world. Whether you're a collector, a fan of surprises, or just love the beautiful game, our mystery boxes bring excitement and football culture straight to your wardrobe.Each shirt is carefully sourced and checked for quality before being sent out — you’ll receive a premium replica in brand-new condition, all at a great price. We work hard to provide a fun, fast, and reliable experience for football lovers across the UK and beyond.Join thousands of happy customers and discover your next favourite shirt!
Shirt Mystery (shirtmystery.com) has 190 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Showing 97 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
I ordered a mystery shirt for my older son and got barcelona and my younger son a mystery kit and got Alnassr. They are both going to be over the moon Xmas morning, so thank you. My note was listen to "no white" also. Arrived in the 2 week order window Only feedback I can give is individual boxes so they could open them individually. Will definitely order again.
By Liz C.
Excellent. My son was thrilled with his mystery shirt. Excellent communication. Definatley buy again!
By Cat
Great price and even better quality, long waiting time but was well worth the wait, you pay a low price so don’t expect the best delivery, have already ordered again.
By Lewis G.
10/10 would buy again
By Fordey
fantastic shirt Ac Milan away shirt loved it took a while to come but overall fantastic will be ordering again
By Carl M.
Amazing quality, not bad
By Curtis P.
Received a AC Milan special addition shirt, brilliant shirt over the moon with it 🌟
By Scott D.
Amazing shirt. Amazing quality and great price
By Wayne G.
