Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
382 reviews
Island Vacations of Sanibel & CaptivaSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Sanibel Island Vacations offers over 80 quality condos and houses on Sanibel Island. Our team of Certified Guest Service Professionals are knowledgeable about local regulations for the rental community and very familiar with homes and condominiums on the Island. Our goal is to make every island vacation so incredibly special, it will not be forgotten. With a nearly 100% satisfaction rate, we are dedicated to exceeding expectations and are available to answer questions and guide you to the perfect vacation rental. And, if you can’t find what you’re looking for in our inventory, we will work to find it for you! Island Vacations has extensive local knowledge & relationships with other Sanibel accommodation providers and for no additional fee, our team will work to find your vacation rental. The reservation is made through us so you can rest assured you will receive the quality care and attention we’ve been providing guests with for over 20 years. Contact us and let us do the searching so you can start packing your bags and focus on the important stuff like what flip flops to wear!
Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva (sanibelislandvacations.com) has 382 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
382 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The staff at Island Vacations are all very friendly. They called to see if everything was ok with the property and if we needed anything. I’m sure they would have been very responsive if we had any problems.
By Karen
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 23, 2022
Thank you, Karen! So happy you enjoyed your stay.
Island Vacations was very efficient and expedient with check-in, check-out and the one concern we had. They were also very friendly and welcoming.
By Sally
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 17, 2022
Thank you, Sally! We appreciate your review! Sincerely, Fran Peters, owner
We have been coming to Sanibel for over 40 years, and this is the best rental company we have used. Sorry to see some new expenses (cleaning) appear, but I guess that is the result of Covid.
By Elizabeth
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 17, 2022
We are so happy you are with Island Vacations and look forward each year to your return! Thank you for your nice comments!
We have used Island Vacations for about 15 years. They are helpful, reliable and professional. I highly recommend them if you are interested in renting a property.
By Kelley
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 16, 2022
Thank you so much, Kelley! We appreciate your kind review of the staff and Island Vacations!
Another great time on Sanibel. Best beach to walk right outside. Great shelling , soft sand and dolphins. Quiet condo complex with nice walk around lagoon.
By Donna
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 10, 2022
Sounds wonderful - thank you for your comments!
The office staff was completely responsive to all our requests! In a very timely manner.
By Patti & R.
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 10, 2022
Thank you so much! We look forward to your return visit next year! Fran
Place wAs very nice Only issues were laundry in dryer when we arrived and broken drawer in master bedroom dresser.Door key stuck on each use Minor issues but that’s why it’s 4 star
By Ronald
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 10, 2022
We appreciate your feedback. I do hope the staff at Island Vacations was accommodating! And we will check on the drawer and front door lock. Thank you! Sincerely, Fran
The staff is courteous and efficient.
By Monte & Jill G.
Response from Island Vacations of Sanibel & Captiva· Feb 10, 2022
Thank you Monte & Jill.
