Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
71 reviews
pupper crustSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Curated boxes of premium dog toys and treats hand-selected from small businesses across the United States.
pupper crust (puppercrust.com) has 71 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
71 approved reviews, newest moderated first
1st time ordering from Pupper Crust for our new pup and I was very pleasantly surprised. I feel like everything was hand picked with a theme for my boy. The toys were very cute and the treats are so healthy, which is exactly why I chose Pupper Crust. I love that I'm supporting small businesses. Such a great company!
By Taryn G.
Fast shipping quality items
By Brian L.
Pupper Crust is a fantastic dog subscription box! The treats and toys are top quality, and my pup is always excited to see what’s inside each month. Highly recommend for any dog owner looking to spoil their furry friend!
By Alyssa
my dog has been destroying EVERY toy with her new adult teeth. the toys that came in her box have managed to hold up to them. loved the treats too. knowing the company is supporting small businesses too is a plus :)
By Mahkayla D.
Great quality treats and pup looooves the toys ❤️
By Karine
Love the carefully sourced treats and toys! The value exceeds the cost by 2-3x
By Kasi S.
The toys were so cute and high quality. Both toys provided quality enrichment time when I tried them out and Tzatziki had fun playing with them. Now when he sees me grab the squash, he’s already sitting and waiting for me to set it down for him to pounce. Also, I received a quick response when I emailed about my dogs allergies to duck and peanut butter. Plus they went above and beyond to follow up and make sure the toys were an appropriate size for my pup.
By Mallory & T.
