Pencil Order
Our order was done quickly and correctly.
By CRPD
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 22, 2022
thank you, enjoy the pencils! Brian - Pencil Guy
Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
725 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Personalized and blank pencils - lowest prices and quickest service! Can ship same or next day! Five star rated on amazon - Pencil Guy!
Pencilguyshop (pencilguyshop.com) has 725 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
725 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Our order was done quickly and correctly.
By CRPD
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 22, 2022
thank you, enjoy the pencils! Brian - Pencil Guy
Fast service, great communication and nice quality pencils- thank you!
By Melissa T.
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 22, 2022
Thanks, appreciate the positive feeback! enjoy your pencils - Brian - Pencil Guy
Pencils are fine. Nothing special. Order was late and there was no communication regarding delivery until I reached out. By then there was nothing I could do. I would have cancelled if I had known because I now have a bunch of pencils and no reason for them.
By Jane S.
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 17, 2022
Hi Jane We saw that you put a one star review on Trustpilot today. We received your order on 7/29 and shipped it on 8/5 five working days. The pencils were delivered on 8/9 via free fedex ground shipping We sent you a proof on 7/29 that you approved, but you did not indicate a need by date. If you had indicated that you had a must in hand date, we would have shipped the pencils earlier so you would have had them for your event. We can either refund your pencils or send you another 1000 at no charge. Please advise. We apologize for this miscommunication. [email protected] pencilguyshop.com
Fast efficient service. We were so happy with our pencils!!!
By Joy J.
Products look good, quality is nice and service was fast. thanks!
By Jeremy P.
Pencilguyshop was the cheapest we could find for custom pencils (random assortment of neon colored barrels), and they did not disappoint! The design process was simple and quick, the pencils arrived within a week and a half (standard shipping), and we got a pretty even distribution of the five colors (not 1/3 pink, as has happened from other sites before). They even boxed the pencils into smaller boxes, ~144 per box! Very useful.
By Read-Aloud Volunteer P.
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 16, 2022
thanks for your positive words, enjoy your pencils! Brian
Great communication and excellent product. Pencils were for my daughters campaign for school president. They were professionally made and her “slogan” really stood out. Perfect giveaway. Thank you
By Matt P.
Pencilguyshop was so great to work with! I needed some pencils for a school function very quickly, on short notice, and they were super communicative and assured me my order would arrive in time. It even arrived earlier than promised, and the pencils look great. Plus, free shipping is awesome.
By Jennifer
Response from Pencilguyshop· Aug 16, 2022
thanks Jennifer for your kinds words, enjoy your pencils!