Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
287 reviews
Old Trading PostSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Old Trading Post is unique as we offer our customers products ranging from manufactured goods to custom handmade products in most of our product categories. We have assembled products lines which can accommodate virtually any Western Lifestyle needs from the everyday cowboy and cowgirl to the weekend re-enactor. We have an extensive resume in outfitting projects in theatres, television and movie productions and doing research and development on special needs leather projects. The Old Trading Post is a family-owned and operated business. Since its establishment in 1998, the Skier family have supplied thousands of satisfied customers with our quality Western Gun Leather, Western Wear including Buckskin Apparel, Western Shirts & Leather Chaps, Western Boots, Western Hats and other unique Western Apparel products.
Old Trading Post (oldtradingpost.com) has 287 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
287 approved reviews, newest moderated first
One star is a way to high rating for this piece of crap rip off outfit. Like many others I have been waiting over 13 months for my order a holster and gun belt. Repeated inquiries online and on the phone have gotten nothing but false promises and lies. Mike keeps saying they will refund or ship but never follows thru. Seems to be a dishonest, lying, SCAMMING outfit. Plan to contact my State Attorney General to look into this deal.
By MICHAEL T R.
This company is a total scam. Ripped me off for $190 for two holsters ordered on October 16th of 2023, never received. Mike is the ultimate scammer and always has a reason why you haven't received the product. In truth, it's just because he is a scam artist figuring ways to steal your money. This company should be shut down.
By Robert S.
This family business ripped me off over $400. I ordered a western gun belt they stole off El Paso Saddlery website. During the wait time, they billed and collected from my Visa card, who can do nothing now. Mike S has e mailed me several times with “ just 2 weeks” or,” guarantee you will receive at the end of next week” on 2 different times. He has no honor, and will lie through his teeth to you, without a thought.He has promised me a full refund twice. Their business address is actually a crappy apartment. Do not do business with these crooks.
By Don H.
I will NEVER do business with this company again. First I ordered a holster with a 4 month delivery date. Four months came and went. Several inquires produced promises but no holster. Finally, the holster shipped but it was not what I ordered. Fella at Old Trading Post blamed the problem on Covid-19, and his inability to hire good help. Like a fool I then ordered a leather military magazine pouch. Delivery was also promised in four months. After 4 months I made inquiry about the order and was told that "the order fell thru the cracks due to personnel issues."
By Kiowa W.
Ordered a holster on May 2024. Promised three months. It’s now been 10 months. Even time they promised 2 weeks for delivery and nothing. I’ve been promised a refund three times and no refund delivered. This company promises great products but they aren’t delivering either product or refunds. Jim Wertman
By JIM W.
I placed an order (42839) on October 17, 2023. It's now November 2024. I've never received the item. I've called Old Trading Post more than a dozen times asking for a refund. No response. No refund.
By Andrew K.
Order 43067 Ordered on 11/26/2023 $352.01 Not delivered as of 10/12/2024 Mike S full of BS on reason for no delivery. very very poor company service. Do not buy leather good from this company.
By Francis R.
I ordered a holster on 5-29-22 and never received it. I have been promised the item or a refund for over 18 months and have received neither. Never buy from this company!
By David M.
