Alice is amazing
The store had a sale I missed, but Alice was amazingly kind and offered the sale anyway. Truly made my year and a fiancé! Thank you Alice🙏🏽
By Jan-Dore
Thursday, November 5, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
222 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The largest selection of custom jewelry designs and rare gemstones. All created in house. Family owned. Located in northwest Indiana near Chicago.
Moriarty's Gem Art (moregems.com) has 222 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
222 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The store had a sale I missed, but Alice was amazingly kind and offered the sale anyway. Truly made my year and a fiancé! Thank you Alice🙏🏽
By Jan-Dore
I purchased a gem during the livestream. The stone was 25% off. Great value beautiful stone (color/cut/clarity was exactly as disclosed).'Shipping time was super fast and efficient
By VALUED CUSTOMER robert K.
Wonderful experience! I would definitely recommend Moriarity’s, with enthusiasm. Professional, courteous, responsive business with quality materials, exactly as advertised.
By Irene
Lovely custom piece! The stone is amazing! And the nail they designed is just perfect to “show case” the stone, but not distract from it. I gave purchased several custom as well as set pieces. All are of outstanding quality & customer service is top notch! Thank you!
By Vv
Alice and team are very quick and responsive. Provided me with regular updates on the process and did not skip a beat in providing excellent customer service.
By Hector G.
Used to be known for unique stuff but not it sells overpriced items only
By Carly A.
Response from Moriarty's Gem Art· May 20, 2025
Thanks for your feedback. I couldn’t find a record of you as a customer, but I still wanted to respond. All of our jewelry is still handcrafted in-house by our family, using gemstones we source directly through our travels to Africa and Asia. Each stone is custom-cut by master gem cutter Steve Moriarty, making our pieces truly one of a kind. As for pricing, any adjustments are based strictly on market changes—gold, for example, has risen over 30% in the past year, which directly impacts our costs. We take all feedback seriously, so if you have a specific experience you'd like to share, I’d love to hear more so we can continue improving for our customers.
My fantastic 3.75ct cambodian electric blue loose stone was more than i even expected! Will definitely follow the youtube channel and be ready for more purchases. The full disclosure and details of the stone will add value to my collection and beneficiaries! thanks for the 25% off !
By gerda K.
Amazing designs available at a reasonable rates
By Marcos R.