Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Poor
597 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Jersey Mike's Subs is listed under General Restaurants.
Jersey Mike's Subs (jerseymikes.com) has 597 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 2.1 out of 5.
597 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Ordered two of the same Italian subs two different days, no hot peppers ( because I get sick for two days after eating) and only mayonnaise, first one had no mayonnaise and was dripping with oil, second one had mayonnaise and was loaded with hot peppers
By Jim S.
I used to Love, Love, Love Jersey Mike's Subs. Today all of that changed. I went and ordered a #8 Club. While they were slicing the cheese. It was sliced so thin I could literally see through it and see the yeast bubbles in the bread. Also the meat was sliced the same way. I was so disappointed that I canceled my order left the deli and wrote this review. I hope my fellow sandwitch connoisseur's read this review thoroughly and tell Jersey Mike's Company Representatives that this is unfair and undesirable.
By Kim W.
I had a steak and cheese. It had very little meat for the price . So, too expensive, for the sandwich I got. I have heard good things about their Italians and other cold subs with deli meat, but am afraid to try anything else from there.
By Scott M.
The manager of Creve Coeur Missouri stole money. Angela kemmis Cooper. I remember her name. Not a good person
By Venosta J.
Price is way up for a roll with meat so thin you can see through it hardly any tomato and onion don't know what happened to this place but they all are going down hill subway is cheaper and make a pretty decent sandwich now that they corrected their ways but don't waste your money at Jersey mikes
By John C.
The over all quality of the sandwiches is fantastic. I don't like the fact they cut the bread in half. Every good sub I've had most of my 67years the bread is hinged. I would of given Jersey Mike's a 5 star rating had not cut the bread in half. It's a lot harder to enjoy with the insides squeezing out of all 4 sides.
By Bob L.
Ripoff. 11 dollars for regular size (which is about 7/8 the size of a crappy Subway sub) roast beef sub. I didn't want it "Mike's way," so it came with a scanty amount of roast beef, a bushel of lettuce and a stale roll. The tomatoes were tasteless, probably genetically-raised garbage. I won't be going back.
By Arthur Z.
Not good. My first and last time. Bread was stuffed with lettuce, onion, tomatoes. He put on two slices of paper thin cheese, turkey and ham.
By Linda
