We bought a bottle of Opus One for a…
We bought a bottle of Opus One for a wedding gift. Jim was very quick to ship and took the time to double check the address and make sure the included note was correct.
By palmer E.
Sunday, November 8, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
198 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
FineWineCollector.com specializes in California "cult" wines, and First and Second Growth Bordeaux. We also frequently acquire and sell the best wines of Burgundy, Rhone, Italy and Australia. We only purchase wine that has been stored properly, and all of our wines are kept in temperature and humidity controlled wine refrigerators at our facility in San Jose, California. Not only do we sell the finest wines, but also, according to Wine-Searcher.com, we often have the lowest retail prices in the entire country!
FineWineCollector.com (finewinecollector.com) has 198 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
198 approved reviews, newest moderated first
We bought a bottle of Opus One for a wedding gift. Jim was very quick to ship and took the time to double check the address and make sure the included note was correct.
By palmer E.
Fast delivery, wines well packed, fair price !
By Eric S.
I know nothing about fine wine. I was searching for fine California Pinot Noir as a gift for a friend. I read an article in which Sea Smoke wine was mentioned. I found it on the website along with another brand that was also highly rated. I bought both and my friend was familiar with both and was excited to receive the gift.
By Cliff Zlotnik, Ideaz, L.
Terrific customer service. Jim followed up after I placed the order and confirmed all of the details including the shipping. If the opportunity presented itself will definitely order from again.
By Harry L D.
Very good Experience
By Customer
This is my first purchase from FWC, and I am sure will buy again.
By Leon T.
Good answer to who is who Jim is a good guy to talk to
By Marvin M.
Response from FineWineCollector.com· May 8, 2019
Hi this is Edward. I am the founder and original owner of FineWineColkector.com. Although Jim Shaw now owns and does a great job of running the company he still consults me and I monitor our reviews.
EASY to deal with: service was prompt & EXACTLY as described in advance!
By Stanley H.