Ruth was very warm and easy to talk to
Ruth was very warm and easy to talk to. Listened to my concern and cancelled my order with no questions asked.
By John N.
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
26 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Sports Memorabilia and Collectibles shop where fans can find Autographed and Signed Memorabilia for your favorite team. Shop Collectible Trading Cards, Ball, Bats, Photos and our exclusive memorabilia only available at Fanatics Authentic.
Fanaticsauthentic (fanaticsauthentic.com) has 26 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
26 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Ruth was very warm and easy to talk to. Listened to my concern and cancelled my order with no questions asked.
By John N.
Ruth did a great job quickly getting to the problem and addressing my concerns
By ANDREW M.
I just wanted to take the time to thank Ruth for being the upmost professional. It was a joy and impactful call, just how she cares about the people calling and takes the time to get to know them well helping with the problem at hand. Definitely went in angry and ended the call with a smile on my face. 100% would acknowledge any customer service representative that is as kind and professional as her thank you again Ruth
By Ronnie G.
I received the wrong item. The photo from the listing which I purchased showed no damage. What I ended up receiving was in poor shape and damaged. On their website they were advertising a damaged copy of similar to what I ordered for half the price (Again, what I ordered was supposedly in mint condition). What I received and the photos on this listing were identical. In short, I paid more for a damaged copy they were advertising at half price. I reached out to customer service and they were no help. Told me the warehouse said I was wrong and what I received was correct even though I sent them photos as proof. Ultimately, I would just avoid the hassle of dealing with them.
By RS
I received the wrong item. Ruth and James provided excellent customer service in making sure the correct item got reshipped to me right away.
By BG
I ordered my sweatshirt on September 25, and its not supposed to ship until November 13. Almost 2 months to get product make sure people are aware if they want a gift fast or in a reasonable amount of time, not to order from Fanatics!
By Henry T.
Sarah was very helpful and has quick response. She provided me a very good customer service and I recommend her.
By Shuman
Matthew was a great help. He was quick to respond. He was clear in what he needed to assist me and when I sent him what he needed, he resolved my issue extremely quickly. He was kind.
By T.T.