I have only used Elfster for a year
I have only used Elfster for a year, but it is so easy to navigate and find the perfect gift for everyone on your gift list.
By Charlene Stout C.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
75 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Elfster is a proprietary software application providing social networking features related to "secret Santa" style gift exchanges.
Elfster (elfster.com) has 75 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.0 out of 5.
75 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I have only used Elfster for a year, but it is so easy to navigate and find the perfect gift for everyone on your gift list.
By Charlene Stout C.
So helpful for getting things for my hard-to-buy for people. And the support elves fix any issues that arise
By Charles
I love Elfster for maintaining wishlist throughout the year. Birthdays, Christmas, book clubs, galantines and so many other reasons. I love how easy it is to add to a wishlist by their recommended items or copy and pasting from a website. Functions to use restricted draws so every year people draw different names and not the same person. Also most recently I’ve had to remove a participant and Elfster easily redraws the name with very little effort.
By Hellen
I’ve been using Elfster since 2022. It is so easy and fun to do exchanges through their website / app. Having the ability to make wishlists for not only myself but my kids as well, literally takes the guess work out of holiday shopping!
By Amber L.
Awesome company, easy to navigate 10 out of 10 recommend!
By Amy
We use Elfster to do Boo baskets and Christmas Cheer baskets. It is a fun way to spread neighborhood cheer and to have fun doing so. Elfster makes it easy to manage getting assigned a name and checking off when you have dropped your basket.
By Jennifer Ann B.
Elfster has been such a useful resource for so many holidays for my friends and family. From gift exchanges to sharing my kids' wishlist before their birthday, I know things will go smoothly thanks to Elfster!
By Aire Plichta R.
We used elfster for holiday neighborhood exchanges in our old neighborhood and it was always so fun! Would definitely recommend! Wish our new neighborhood would do something like it.
By Brittany