Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
592 reviews
The Deadbolt Mystery SocietySelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
The Deadbolt Mystery Society is a monthly subscription box service for lovers of mystery and suspense. With your subscription, a new mystery box filled with puzzles, evidence, and interviews will be delivered to your door. Each box is a standalone mystery that requires no additional boxes to complete.
The Deadbolt Mystery Society (deadboltmysterysociety.com) has 592 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
592 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Prompt delivery. I've gotten 3 boxes in the past. Really challenging, but fun. Good for a group.
By Walt M.
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 24, 2024
Walt, thanks so much! We are so glad that you are enjoying our mysteries! Thanks for taking the time to leave us a review.
We love doing these mysteries for date night. It is so much fun!!!!
By Mickey
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 24, 2024
We are very happy that our mysteries bring you together for date night! Thanks for being a part of our DMS family, Mickey!
This company does such an amazing job with product creation and production. I have really enjoyed all the mysteries and their service is top notch!
By Amy
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
Hi, Amy! Thanks so much! We really appreciate those glowing remarks. We enjoy having you as a part of our DMS family!
I bought the "Fall of the House of Asher" game box at Cryptid Con and played it for the first time on New Year's Eve. My friends and I were consumed by the game for a solid three hours, we had SO much fun! I love how it came with a little collector card and sticker too to commemorate solving the mystery! I bought six more boxes the next morning LOL can't wait to solve more mysteries!
By Maureen B.
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
This is incredible, Maureen! We are so happy to hear you are loving our mysteries. Thanks for coming to see us at Cryptid Con! We are already looking forward to returning this year.
Great puzzles! We’ve only done three- the downloadable few. They were so fun. Great stories. And just the right amount of difficulty. Tricky puzzles but not so hard that it’s a stretch to see what the writers were going for (some puzzles try to twist it so much to make it hard that the answer makes no sense). Highly recommend!
By JS
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
We love this! Thanks for checking out our digital downloads. Welcome to the DMS family!
Love DMS! Always a great mystery to solve and wonderful customer service. I tell everyone I can about this company.
By Alexis T.
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
Awww, we appreciate that! We love you, Alexis!
I absolutely love the fact that you can download games now!! I've purchased all 3 games and have really enjoyed playing them. I hope you put out more in the near future!!
By Staci
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
Yay! Thanks for checking out our digital downloads! We have more in the pipeline with those. So, stay tuned!
DMS boxes have become our favorite night-in activity! We order one time boxes on top of our subscription! So much fun and the best of this style activity out there! Great puzzles and well thought out scenarios! 10/10
By Leslie K.
Response from The Deadbolt Mystery Society· Jan 12, 2024
Thanks so much, Leslie! We are grateful that you choose to spend your time and money with us. We appreciate your continued support! Here's to mystery solving in 2024!
