Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
426 reviews
Craft HolstersSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We specialize in production of custom leather holsters, designed to fit everyday carry needs of any responsible gun owner. If you're looking for comfortable, safe, and enjoyable carry experience, Craft Holsters is a place to go to.
Craft Holsters (craftholsters.com) has 426 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
426 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I must update my review. I was afraid to crank the screws down on my new kydex holster. Then I realized why the metal hardware. For precisely that reason. If you have that problem(too loose weapon falls out) crank "em down they can take it.
By Rick B.
Excellent customer service & communication! Quality of product is excellent! Fit and finish of my holster is perfect: true craftsmanship. Highly recommend this company! 👍
By Mike P.
I bought a shoulder holster for a Sig P365 Xmacro with Red Dot. Almost no break-in is needed. Fit great. There are 2 things I would change. One is the slider lock on the shoulder straps. I wish they were tighter to the strap. Maybe a wider piece of the current metal slider. The other would be able to get the model with the non-removable holster for the Sig P365 Xmacro Red Dot. Your website currently shows it isn't available. Other than that this is a very nice rig made with quality material. AA++.
By Chris C.
I watched a you tube review of craft holsters and decided to give them a try. I ordered an IWB holster for an H&K pistol I had which was hard to find a decent holster for. I was quoted it would arrive at a certain date. The holster arrived several days before the date and I was extremely pleased with the fit and quality of the holster. So pleased I placed an additional order. I think this is a great value.
By Lloyd C.
Craftholsters provides a holster for every type of pistol. In my case, it is a Sig Sauer P226 Custom, for which they provide a custom-made holster that fits perfectly, and which was quite reasonably priced. The holster, as do most leather products of any kind, requires a 'break in', and this is easily accomplished by bagging the pistol, jambing it into the holster forcefully, and soaking the holster in wood alcohol. After 24 hours, the holster is ready to use, and accommodates the pistol perfectly. I give these guys my highest recommendation for quality craftsmanship at any price.
By ROBERT W.
1st the prices are excellent for the quality of the products, the shipping is fast and the customer service is absolutely fantastic! They are extremely helpful. They have several custom holster options for just about every firearm.
By christopher J.
Best site and company to get your holster from.
By Phillip H.
28 day's to wait for a premium holster that cost $109, the breaking in process is near impossible without theirs or a leather softener. Security Snap Retention wasn't nearly long enough regardless of stretching, had to cut it off then sand smooth with my dremel to remove sharp edges. Never reached out about a refund as I'm somewhat happy, however the reassurance of the warranty being voided and how they can't help me with a claim that I never...claimed; was not only appropriate but greatly appreciated thanks Filip.
By Cody S.
Response from Craft Holsters· Oct 12, 2023
Hey sir! I'm very sorry to hear you couldn't be happy with your new holster the way it came in. Unfortunately, when it comes to wet-molded holsters, despite every single one of them being checked for a perfect fit after they are made, they sometimes tend to shrink a bit (including straps) on their way to you as the fresh leather is drying out while in transit. That's why a proper break-in is sometimes simply inevitable. I'm sorry to hear you weren't happy with how your feedback was handled, but I my colleague was just following our standard procedure. It's quite important to let us know about any problem you might have with a particular holster before you decide to fix it yourself. When it comes to how long it took for the holster to be delivered, please, take into account that if you order something that's not available in stock for the configuration you select, it has to be made first, which is why we always notify you guys of both stock availability as well as estimated production time and delivery date. If you wish to pursue a claim, let me know at my email address ([email protected]) or simply reply here, but include your order number too, please (6 digits). Once again, I apologize for the trouble caused and I thank you for your understanding when it comes to our returns/warranty terms. Regards, Al from Craft Holsters
