Products are well crafted
Products are well crafted. Customer service is outstanding
By William H.
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
135 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
CollegiateSet designs and prints stylish licensed t-shirts, tank tops, hoodies, and sweats for colleges and universities in the United States. Founded by graduates from Albion College, we specialize in smaller schools that may not have a lot of online options for their school's apparel. Shop now for the student, alumni, family member, or school supporter in your life! CollegiateSet is a division of CreateMyTee and all of our apparel is proudly designed and printed in Michigan.
CollegiateSet (collegiateset.com) has 135 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.7 out of 5.
135 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Products are well crafted. Customer service is outstanding
By William H.
I placed an order that USPS never delivered. I emailed customer service and they were on top of it. They resent my order with no problems. I ordered a sweatshirt for my sister as a Christmas present and I can't wait to give it to her! I will be shopping with this company again!
By Jessica B.
Good quality sweatshirt and received quickly - thank you!
By Elizabeth M.
My order was delivered less than a week after I ordered it! The sweatshirt is very good quality and the printing looks awesome!
By Carli H.
The order for a hooded sweatshirt was delivered in a timely manner as promised, I would only suggest they would expand their return policy from seven days to thirty days as our purchase is a Christmas gift and will not be opened for a few weeks beyond our purchase date. If, by some chance, the size we purchased is too small, it would be nice if they accepted an exchange for a larger size.
By Howard
Response from CollegiateSet· Nov 21, 2023
Hi Howard, Thanks for your review! Our default policy is seven days, but we know Christmas time is a little different and we would much rather you order early than wait until the last minute. So please don't hesitate to reach out after Christmas if the size doesn't work and our team will take care of you!
Efficient delivery. Well constructed product. School recently changed mascot & this store was among few to offer the up to date design.
By DDH
I received the T - shirt as indicated and received notification of the shipment while it was in the process.
By Debbie P.
Shirt exactly as it was advertised. High quality fabric and decal. It will make a great birthday present for my son.
By Laura
Response from CollegiateSet· Nov 1, 2023
Thanks for your kind review, Laura! We're so glad to help out with a birthday present!