So far the cigars have been very good .
So far the cigars have been very good .
By Paul S.
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
257 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
CigarClub is a cigar membership and gift shop that handpicks cigars for you based on your taste preferences.
CigarClub (cigarclub.com) has 257 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
257 approved reviews, newest moderated first
So far the cigars have been very good .
By Paul S.
Quality cigars. Reasonable price. Great opportunity to experience a variety of cigars
By Jason
Great gift for cigar lovers. My brother in law loves his monthly deliveries. And best of all he likes the quality of the cigars he has received.
By Kim Levitan S.
Great stuff
By Diana V.
Good cigars and timely delivery
By Harry W.
Fast shipping and an excellent price on great cigars. I was delighted with the selected cigars of the month. Thank you cigar club!
By Matthew S.
This was a complete waste of 89 dollars. They sent me ALL budget cigars that would have costs me less had I bought the same ones from my local humidor.
By Charlie
Multiple factors go into enjoying a cigar such as flavor, strength, gage and length. I prefer a stronger, at least 5" length and a thicker gage cigars. I was given this as a present for Christmas. over the 21 I received, 2 were thicker gage, 3 were a length of 5" and over, and 5 were close to full bodied, the rest were light to medium bodied. Most were dry, and some unraveled, and did not have a consistent smoke. these were not something i would ever smoke. When sending my concerns, I was told that the only factor they put into their cigar shipments was strength. When I replied back with my concerns I was basically informed they did not matter. Terrible experience from my end,
By Michael