The cigars were very smooth and had a…
The cigars were very smooth and had a great subtle flavor
By Thomas P.
Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
257 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
CigarClub is a cigar membership and gift shop that handpicks cigars for you based on your taste preferences.
CigarClub (cigarclub.com) has 257 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
257 approved reviews, newest moderated first
The cigars were very smooth and had a great subtle flavor
By Thomas P.
All the cigars were dry and stale
By Matthew S.
Good variety and quality. Not huge which makes them convenient.
By Truthful Reviews for Y.
I used to use a different cigar subscription brand, but they sent cigars in unsealed cardboard boxes with zero humidity control. Cigar Club always uses sealed bags with humidity packs inside. That alone would be enough for me to switch companies. But CigarClub also has amazing and responsive customer service, and a great selection of random cigars every month (I don't think I've gotten the same one twice, yet).
By John R.
I actually love the packages they’re amazing, and my boyfriend absolutely loves the cigar selection. The quality of the cigars is excellent. The only issue we’ve experienced is with the delivery time. We usually get charged for priority delivery, but it still takes too long often shipped on the 5th and not received until the 20th or later. Even on my first order, I paid for priority shipping and still had a long wait. Other than the shipping delays, everything else has been great. The cigars themselves are top quality, and we truly enjoy them.
By MERCY A.
Slow orders and cigars are ok
By Aaron L.
Great selection and variety.
By Stephen C.
The selection was great. Nice variety of cigars
By James Z.