Monday, November 2, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
92 reviews
Atlanta Gold & Coin BuyersSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers, located in Johns Creek, GA, is a full-service coin and bullion dealer specializing in buying, selling and appraising old and rare coins, coin collections and gold, silver, platinum and palladium coins and bullion. Family-owned and operated, we place an emphasis on transparency, concierge service and building relationships with our customers, all of which is backed by our same day price lock guarantee. We are an A+ rated member of the Better Business Bureau, the winner of Kudzu’s Atlanta Coin Dealer of the Year Award, authorized NGC and PCGS coin dealers, a lifetime member of the American Numismatic Association, a Roundtable Trading partner and possess an excellent reputation with customers and industry associates.
Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers (atlantagoldandcoin.com) has 92 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
92 approved reviews, newest moderated first
This is the place you want to visit. They are very knowledgeable. They were great in explaining things to me and making sure I understood everything. I highly recommend them and I will be returning there soon!
By Karen A.
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Oct 2, 2025
Hi Karen - We're happy to hear that you had a positive experience and that you felt comfortable with the process. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Amazing experience. I have no idea what the complaints are about. Service is exceptional, value is unprecedented and follow up is impeccable. Give these folks a chance cause they will amaze you.
By I A.
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Oct 2, 2025
We're thrilled that you had a positive experience and that you shared your experience with other potential customers. We do our best to try and promptly respond to any questions. Thanks again for your business!
I had a great experience. The guys at Atlanta Gold and Coin are very upfront with what they can and can’t service (jewelry, pennies, etc.), but will work hard to help you with buying or selling needs. Collin went above and beyond to help me get a competitive return on my gold and silver. I learned a lot in my visit as I did not know as much about this process before. Collin is a great guy and was very patient. I will definitely be back.
By Lisa B.
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Oct 2, 2025
Hi Lisa - We're happy to hear that you had a positive experience with Collin. While we would love to purchase all of our customers' items, there are a few things that we don't have a market for or that our business license doesn't encompass. We look forward to working with you again in the future!
Hunter was very professional and thorough
By Albert L.
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Oct 2, 2025
Hi Albert - Thanks for the kind words. It was nice meeting and doing business with you. Feel free to reach back out if we can be of assistance in the future.
Outstanding people to deal with. Honest and accurate always.
By Don B.
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Oct 2, 2025
Hi Don - Thanks for the kind words. I appreciate it. Always a pleasure to deal with you as well! Sincerley, Tony
I felt a bit lowballed on my coin collection. They pointed out every tiny flaw, which I understand, but the final number was disappointing. The guy was polite, sure. I just expected a better offer for what I had. I walked out without selling.
By Han
Response from Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers· Sep 16, 2025
Hi Han - Thanks for reaching out. We looked through our appointment calendar and don't have a record of meeting with anyone by your name. Are you sure you met with Atlanta Gold & Coin in Johns Creek? If so, please give us a call at 404-236-9744 so we can discuss your experience. If it was with someone else, we would kindly ask that you remove the review at your earliest opportunity. Sincerely, Hunter
I have done business with Atl Gold & Coin for. several years and they are trusted and honest. They are a good source for information on the markets in precious metals. Hunter and Tony are professional and always willing to help make a transaction safe and with no pressure.
By Atlanta T.
I found Hunter to be very knowledgeable and prepared for our appointment. He had done some research based on my pictures I sent him and was ready when I got there. He was thorough going through the collection I bought him and explained everything very clearly. He is fair, honest and I felt totally comfortable with the process, his assessment and pricing. It is scary to trust a collection to someone when you know nothing about coins. I trust Hunter.
By Pam
