Nick & Don are good people and have…
Nick & Don are good people and have been associated with them along time.No B.S. Recommend them anytime.....
By MILO
Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
658 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We buy, sell, trade, appraise and consign rare coins and gold, platinum, silver and palladium bullion.
American Federal Coin & Bullion (americanfederal.com) has 658 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
658 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Nick & Don are good people and have been associated with them along time.No B.S. Recommend them anytime.....
By MILO
Have always had good experiences in dealing with American Federal. They go the extra mile in being a dealer you can count on and trust. Also there have been times I did not act on Nick's reccos and wish that I would have later.
By JEFFREY
Would recommend American Federal for both selling and buying. Very reputable and did a good job of disposing a large amount of my coins.
By EASTLAKE
Took time to listen and serve us
By DAVID
American Federal Rare Coin provides great customer service, high integrity at very competitive prices. I highly recommend them!
By DAVID H.
I keep recommending people to you, I know someday I will get a good wonderful deal from you when I order coins for my portfolio. Last couple days I spoke with you regarding inventory sheets for my inventory I currently have. I have not received them yet. Please send me copies of your inventory sheets to start logging in my coins and see what their values are today. Thank you,
By Carlos T.
Nice coin and fast service. Good communication.
By Milton Home O.
Honest,fair company.
By JOHN