carl was prompt and answered my…
carl was prompt and answered my questions as always. now just waiting for shipment
By customer
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses

The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
658 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We buy, sell, trade, appraise and consign rare coins and gold, platinum, silver and palladium bullion.
American Federal Coin & Bullion (americanfederal.com) has 658 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.
658 approved reviews, newest moderated first
carl was prompt and answered my questions as always. now just waiting for shipment
By customer
Everyone that I have ever had contact with at AmFed is extremely friendly, professional and efficient. Nick fairly prices his merchandise and will always take the time to educate you and answer any questions you may have. No hard sell from this company. They also pay a fair price if you want to sell to them regardless of where you originally purchased the items. It is truly a two-way street with them. I highly recommend American Federal and the team that makes this a great and trusted company.
By ALAN T.
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Oct 7, 2026
Thank you so very much for your 5 star review! Whether you have been working with us for the last 40 years or 1st time buyer/seller, we treat everyone with the highest respect. Our attitude is that we are here for you!
Great folks and easy to work with
By Yooper M.
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Oct 7, 2026
Thank you so very much for your 5 star review! We definitely try to make things simple for all our customers whether a buyer or seller!
Great people
By Darrell M.
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Oct 7, 2026
Thank you so very much for your 5 star review! We strive to be great!
Very quick and easy transaction !!!!!
By John
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Sep 30, 2026
Thank you so much for your 5 star review! We believe in keeping things simple
real nice people, vs salespersons!
By Debra
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Sep 30, 2026
Thank you very much for your 5 star review! Thank you for the compliment. We treat our clients like we would our own family members. Genuine, honest, and never pushy
Don Gause is a pleasure to do business with.
By Joe
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Sep 30, 2026
Thank you for your 5 star review. We value Don and his expertise which is incredibly valuable with his almost 40 years with the company.
JP was honest straight to the point and careful the answer all my questions very professional to tell you the truth. I only wanted to deal with. Nic JP is well on his way. He answered my questions and calm some of my concerns. I really appreciate it. From possible tax, implications to how you could set up an Ira too being comfortable with the mailing system I really appreciate his patience.
By Casey
Response from American Federal Coin & Bullion· Sep 30, 2026
Thank you so very much for your 5 star review! JP is awesome and a great addition to the company which unbelievably is going into his 5th year with us!