Friday, November 6, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Excellent
633 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Wild Idea Buffalo is unlike any other meat company. We began with a vision of actually improving the eco-system of the Great Plains. Our buffalo are raised on the wide open spaces of South Dakota where they eat only the native grasses beneath their feet. They spend their whole lives roaming freely on thousands of acres, and never see a feedlot or slaughterhouse. The result is better lives for the bison, the restoration of over 100,000 acres of the prairie, and sweet, delicious red meat that is actually good for you. Not such a wild idea after all!
Wild Idea Buffalo Co (wildideabuffalo.com) has 633 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
633 approved reviews, newest moderated first
We wanted to say thank you for our first order. We have almost gone through al of our bison and just placed our second order. We were very happy and loved what we got we just had to order some more. Thank you again for what you are doing and we are trying to get the word out to everyone that this is what you want to be serving on your dinner table. Much thanks Todd Gray
By Todd G.
This is thee highest quality bison steak I've ever had. My third order. Not my last.
By Rob S in M.
I was a little apprehensive about ordering from a company I knew little about but really wanted to try there product. The shipping was extremely fast, accuracy of the order was spot on and the product was incredibly good. Great flavor, and texture. I would recommend this company to everyone I know
By Keith E.
We have ordered Bison from other companies before, but Wild Idea Buffalo has the best and the tastiest! My new favorite!
By S. H.
At the request of a friend I went online looking for Bison as our local source was no longer in business. My friend is very familiar with Rapid City so you were an easy choice except....we found another local source too! So I placed my order with you because the information was so clear and well written. Your products arrived in record time and in perfect condition. The meat and sausage is delicious and I plan to order more around the holidays. Thank you, Ruth in Bellingham Washington
By Ruth F.
After my order arrived, I had a question regarding one item. It was a strip of buffalo steak, however it's exact label was not on the sheet included with the shipment. Some items are precook end, others are not. To get a clarification, I sent an email to the address shown on the web site. In the email I apologized for being a neophyte but was not sure if I should eat it or cook it first. The label did not indicate which. I did not get a reply. I have gotten promotional stuff wanting to sell me more, but no answer to my question. Conclusion: they must not want little guy customers like me. I grew up in Nebraska and really expected them to be friendly Guess not
By Thomas B.
Response from Wild Idea Buffalo Co· Oct 26, 2015
Hello Thomas, Thank you for your recent order, we certainly appreciate your support and business. I apologize you did not get a response from anyone. I did look back and I'm unable to find your original email, or any emails from you. We strive ourselves on our excellent customer service and never want to disappoint. Please don't hesitate to call us directly if you should have any other questions we haven't answered: 866-658-6137 or 605-716-0572. Very best from the prairie, Melissa Wild Idea Buffalo Company
The bison was excellent. Used it in a meal I prepared an both my wife an I enjoyed it..It wasn't gamey at all..very good taste..Will most likely order more at a later date.
By James H.
Extremely pleased with the timely delivery, quality of products, packaging and price. I found the ribeye more tender than the strip steak. The pepperoni surprised me as to the taste being comparable to the non buffalo ones that i have eaten over the years. Try it I believe you will not be disappointed. Ted C.
By Ted C.
