Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Great
120 reviews
VinylmnkySelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
Vinylmnky is a leader in new music discovery and expertly curated vinyl experiences. From the popular Breakthrough Record of The Month (BROTM) membership to genre-specific subscription plans curated based on your music taste, Vinylmnky will bolster any vinyl collection. We aim to build our community through high quality service, innovation, customer satisfaction, and passion.
Vinylmnky (vinylmnky.com) has 120 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Showing 2 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters
Nothing about using the membership or how to make selections/changes was sent and recent order is extremely delayed in shipping -15 days since shipping notification and tracking still indicates “label created at sender” as status. Overall, a disappointing program.
By Richard W.
Weird site. I kind of like the whole "monthly subscription" idea (although the catalog is so limited it wouldn't work for me), but the truly bizarre thing is that the site primarily sells vinyl fetishism rather than music. Catalog is the smallest of any record store I've ever seen, including brick & mortar, which might be okay if there seemed to be some kind of guiding principles or aesthetic driving the offerings, but it comes across pretty random, with some quality releases sprinkled in *if* they have hipster appeal (they probably didn't have any Bowie until after he died). Worse, there is no information about any of the releases...not even lists of song titles. But the dead giveaway is the emphasis on framed options. The Vinylmnky tagline might as well be "we sell music for you to look at."
By Clarke R.
Response from Vinylmnky· Aug 26, 2018
Hi, Clarke. I'm sorry you feel negative about our site. Our catalog is limited by design as we feature one debut lp from a breakthrough record per month. The other 170+ albums on the marketplace are ones that we also respect and carry. I'm not sure what you mean about hipster appeal and Bowie. Thank you for the feedback on the list of track titles for the product descriptions. I'll tell you,I have a lot of respect for some albums and had them framed AND in my collection. It's not for everyone though or for every record which is why we give you the option to get this service through a partner company. I hope you enjoy the Bowie Heros album!
