Saturday, November 7, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Average
145 reviews
Vinyl Me, PleaseSelect a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We are storytellers, curators & a community who understand the impact a great album can have on someone. And, we are firm believers that vinyl is the best medium for creating these experiences.We’re fascinated by the long (sometimes grueling) journey a record takes by the time it’s in your hands — from artist to studio to pressing plant, and beyond. Because of our dedication to the process and the people behind it.
Vinyl Me, Please (vinylmeplease.com) has 145 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 3.1 out of 5.
145 approved reviews, newest moderated first
I received this service as a gift, and it was auto renewed costing me over $500. Customer service will not call me back to cancel this subscription. It is very hard to find records of known artists most months, the selection is too obscure for me.
By Travis M.
Fumes released that strained my facial muscles when I opened magazine shipment.
By AB
You guys are s shadow of former self. Monthly picks are pathetic. New format of the club is also no good. Going to give it one more QTR and hoping for improvements.
By Shawn V.
Some how I picked the wrong album for March and can’t delete it, sent 2 emails. YOU NEED A PHONE NUMBER.
By Frankie W.
Selection has gotten a lot worse recently
By Jacob
I like vinyl me please because they have been good at reissuing older albums that are out of print, as well as finding new artists. They are undergoing a transition from an album of the month format to more of a free pick among multiple albums for your membership fee. It is too new to review, but I think it will be good if the choices are broad enough
By Christopher R.
A once excellent service has seemingly fallen apart. Initially gutted to have international shipping taken away, though less so since seeing the continuous changes to RoTM and selections available. As well as ongoing issue fulfilling orders. My order of Black Sabbath’s Master of Reality is only a few weeks off its first birthday (ordered March ‘24). Please send me my record, then I can thankfully not have to think about VMP again. A very unreliable service.
By Steven B.
Just not pleased with the new format and will be deciding whether to keep my membership or move on. What I liked about VMP was the idea that you would select and send me something for me to discover - if I have to pick myself then the likelihood I will pick something I am unfamiliar with is low.
By Kevin A.
