Monday, November 9, 2026 · Customer reviews of US businesses
The Fair Hearing score
Bad
5 reviews
Select a line to read only those reviews.
Honesty, pricing, process and quality scores appear once 5 customers have rated them.
We're a shop for men that love craftsmanship. We offer a curated collection of manly products, such as decanters, wallets, coffee, wooden rings, wooden watches, whiskey glasses, and more.
Vintage Gentlemen (thevintagegentlemen.com) has 5 customer reviews on The Fair Hearing, with an average rating of 1.0 out of 5.
Showing 5 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
I have had a vintage gentleman ring for 3 years now. Within the first year the different materials separated. After two years the gold coating rubbed off completely. The cost of the ring was supposed to be because of the gold content. Turns out its a very thin coating on cheap metal. The quality is a total ripoff. The style and packaging is very nice but these rings DO NOT stand the test of time.
By Sam
Ordered two wedding bands for my husband. After one year, one of the rings broke and the company hasn’t responded to multiple emails even though they state lifetime warranty on their website. If you try and leave a review it has to be submitted first before they post it and they have not posted my honest but bad review. I imagine they do this with every bad review they receive. DO NOT BUY FROM THIS COMPANY. Their rings are cheaply made
By Justine J.
Got 2 rings for our wedding, they sended 1, then told me they were out of stock in the other size, and I can choose another model, also to send back the other ring so they can send 2, I send it back, and for weeks they told me it was about to ship until they stop answering.
By Alejandro
If I could leave zero stars I would. I ordered my husband’s wedding band many months before our wedding on July 20 of 2025. In August 2025 his ring came apart and two pieces. I emailed with the picture of the messed up ring and also sent a picture in message on their Instagram because I was not getting a response. It took me three attempts until I finally got an answer from a person named John. I bought my husband the Atlas ring. I wanted to get another one of those because we liked it so much. They said that they didn’t have another one of those that was a size 9 in stock, but they would get more and 6 to 8 weeks and they would let me know. I waited around patiently and I didn’t receive any messages or emails from them so I had to ask myself and they told me all these excuses of why they didn’t have the ring and so I kept waiting around a little longer. I have been emailing them for August of last year and I just now got a new ring mind you one that I did not want at all. Over the course of emails they said that they would let me choose a ring that was $400 and under for free. I picked a couple rings but one that I got a snarky remark from saying well it did say that on site the nine was out of stock. And remind you, I’m not getting messages from Liz and Charles and Brandon and whoever the hell I’m talking to. I found another size 9 ring, but that was pre-order instead, and I got another snarky remark from that. So I was like I’m not playing these games. You can give me a list of all the size 9 rings that you have available. They sent me three none of which looked like Atlas ring whatsoever so I just decided they need to make it right and sent me a new ring. It did ship really fast but the ring is hideous and I’m just done dealing with these people. These rings are obviously cheaply made. They don’t make them in house. If you look it up, they have like this tiny little warehouse in Florida. I feel like this company is a scam and you might as well spend your money elsewhere. Especially with better customer service and way better quality.
By Anna E.
Pay me commission
By Toni
